|
Post by Zeriel on Nov 4, 2007 18:40:06 GMT -5
I think I'm gonna also go with my former suspicions now that nesta and roosh are cool. vote catinasuit
|
|
|
Post by Zeriel on Nov 4, 2007 19:07:27 GMT -5
wait, for some reason I thought nesta'd confirmed it. unvote catinasuit to avoid any possible irritation
|
|
|
Post by Zeriel on Nov 4, 2007 19:09:06 GMT -5
Can we get a vote count?
|
|
Gir!
FGM
EVIL Demon Goddess Mod
What? Kat is sweet and innocent!
Posts: 691
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by Gir! on Nov 4, 2007 19:58:25 GMT -5
Vote-Counts-R-Us Official Vote Count
CatInASuit (2): Idle Thoughts, dotchanV3 whatthefrak (1): CatInASuit zerial (1): Roosh
|
|
RoOsh
FGM
Former BatMod
[on:Wanna see a magic trick?][of:See You, Space Cowboy....]
Posts: 284
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by RoOsh on Nov 4, 2007 22:16:19 GMT -5
Cat... Here's my Quextion to you.... (since noone's answered my previous ones). I like your thinking. You say there could be 2 scum left. And thusly you are the townie.
Buuut. Then with the 2 scum left you choose WTF over Zeriel. Now... if there ISN'T 2 scum, but only 1... do you find Zeriel less scummy than WTF? Or you really just think that WTF is the play for now? Especially considering that he's never around to defend himself (bad show, really), especially in these shorter days; AND the fact is, if there IS 2 scum, you're going to risk it by voting for the Potential Bodyguard/Doctor Role FIRST... Why not risk voting for Zeriel the claimed townie over WTF the claimed doctor? I find that suspicious....
Unvote Zeriel I'm gonna give you guys 24 to explain thoughts before I cast my vote probably sometime around midnight tomm....
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Nov 4, 2007 23:40:30 GMT -5
I will of course hasten to add, that I could be completely, totally and utterly wrong. Or lying. I think there's two scum left. You and a possible recruit.
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Nov 4, 2007 23:43:45 GMT -5
Idle, are you sure that the mods told you there's a THIRD 50% Doctor? Yes.
|
|
|
Post by CatInASuit on Nov 5, 2007 0:06:33 GMT -5
Cat...Here's my Quextion to you.... (since noone's answered my previous ones). I like your thinking. You say there could be 2 scum left. And thusly you are the townie. Buuut. Then with the 2 scum left you choose WTF over Zeriel. Now... if there ISN'T 2 scum, but only 1... do you find Zeriel less scummy than WTF? Or you really just think that WTF is the play for now? Especially considering that he's never around to defend himself (bad show, really), especially in these shorter days; AND the fact is, if there IS 2 scum, you're going to risk it by voting for the Potential Bodyguard/Doctor Role FIRST... Why not risk voting for Zeriel the claimed townie over WTF the claimed doctor? I find that suspicious.... Unvote ZerielI'm gonna give you guys 24 to explain thoughts before I cast my vote probably sometime around midnight tomm.... To answer, the question. I read back through the posts from WTF and from zeriel (in this current role) and I actually find WTF posts make more sense if he is scum than town. Yes, I know I have voted for a claimed bodyguard, that doesn't mean that said bodyguard cannot be scum. I made my point about there being two scum after I had already voted for WTF in which case it doesn't matter which way I vote. However, in the case there is only one scum left, I think it is more likely to be WTF
|
|
|
Post by CatInASuit on Nov 5, 2007 0:12:57 GMT -5
I will of course hasten to add, that I could be completely, totally and utterly wrong. Or lying. I think there's two scum left. You and a possible recruit. Well, I can be guaranteed of being correct on one thing. That statement is wrong. ;D Idle, are you sure that the mods told you there's a THIRD 50% Doctor? Yes. Just out of curiousity Idle Thoughts, did they say there were 3 x 50% doctors in the game or 3 x 50% pro-town doctors in the game.
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Nov 5, 2007 0:24:55 GMT -5
Okay, extended, idle thoughts. I think there two scum left. There is a small chance there's three but I really think that's pushing it. In fact, I doubt very highly that there's three. Two is more like it. I think the two left are either two original scum or an original scum and a recruit. I'm leaning more toward the latter. For the original scum, I think the best canidate I've seen so far and all through the game is CIAS, as I have since Day One. As for possible recruit..that's trickier. Could be any of you. However going over thoughts, I think that scum would have wanted to: 1. Recruit someone who was trusted, mostly. 2. Recruit someone who they felt was a important or semi-important role 3. Recruit that person early. Being scum in the last game, I know well about recruiting. It stinks the longer you hold it. It's always best to recruit early if you're scum and you have that power/option...because as the game goes on, it's harder and harder to know who you can recruit and who you can't. Of course, this was in the Cult game..in which certain players couldn't be recruited. For all I know, in this game, anyone can be recruited.. So....going by my three beliefs above...I would say that the two that most fit all three the best are: 1. Roosh (who was the first to claim on Day One, had a scum threatening role (one that had half a chance of killing someone who tried to kill him), and was put on the back burner by most the players here until recently). and 2. MadtheSwine/now Dotchan (who was all of confirmed when his brother Diggit was slain because Mad knew the name of the other brother and the rolename). Of these two I'm leaning a bit more toward Dotchan being the one. Not only because of reading all of Roosh's PMs that came along with his claim of Backup Cop, but also because I feel that Mad was the best and closest thing we had to a confirmed player until my accidental first death. At least Roosh was still questionable. Mad's really wasn't. And so.....with much apoligies although a certain part of me can't help but find it also very hilarious.....I find dotchan probably the most suspicious after CIAS. However when we're talking about recruits, really, anyone is up for game. But going by my three thoughts above, I feel the two that fits them the most are the ones I've said. Secondly, I'm still pondering every night when I'm in my bed why Cookies didn't kill off Hal when she had the claim of River Tam the Day right before. I thought long and hard. I thought deep into the night. I laid awake for hours thinking of nothing but that and then I rolled over and thought about it some more. I've been thinking for three days now. And here is what I think. Please note it still won't make total sense..but it may bring more insight to the table so that we can figure out the total sense. The only thing that makes sense to me is killing numbers. Let me go through it all and explain. First of all... 1. Cookies HAD to know Hal was River Tam. He claimed it that Day. So there was no mistake about it, she knew this, yet she chose NOT to kill him. 2. She instead targeted someone she knew NOT to be River Tam but mentioned "switching it over" if something was the case. We don't know what she was refering to or what it depended on for her to switch, but it's obvious that she didn't switch her target that Night so I assume she left it on Hockey, whom she KNEW was not River Tam. 3. The Alliance also killed off one of their own that Night. So....these three things lead me to surmise the next part: A. That come morning (without the thought that she'd slip up and post that for everyone to see), Town would have seen an Alliance member killed. A1. What would we think? Well, I'd guess very strongly that Klutz was killed by another team. A2. There was also the possibility that that Day would have also seen a kill by Panama...which may or may NOT have been an Alliance member. Now this didn't happen, of course. But at the time, scum knew it possibly could, I'd figure. A2a. If the vig kill did happen and it was a Townie...then we'd have, at Dawn, seen an Alliance and Townie killed and everyone would have thought that someone Townie killed the Alliance member and that the Alliance killed the Townie. Everyone.....but the Vig, who would think either: A2a1. The Alliance killed off their own. A2a2. There was a third faction killing people I'm leaning more toward the latter one. I think IF this all happened and WHEN/IF Panama came out with all the info, people would have been more apt to believe that there was a third faction. Then of course there's the direct way.. A2b. If the Vig kill did happen and it was an Alliance member, we would have, at Dawn, seen two Alliance dead...and we'd have thought there was a third faction immediatly, I feel. B. Cookies and the rest of the Alliance didn't want to have an extra kill in there for some reason. This being the extra kill of Hal. Because had she targetted Hal, the person she knew was River Tam, that would have been a possible THREE kills we'd have seen at Dawn. All of the possibilites above....and Hal, of course. C. So I think/feel that Cookies didn't want to have Hal die and be added to the death scene. The only question is....why? Why did they want to hold that kill back? I dunno. Like I said, I don't know the total sense of it...but again, I do have thoughts. C1. It's possible that having Hal die would screw up what they were trying to make people think with the killing of their own. They seemed to want to feed the thought of a third faction and you see, in my A2a and A2b above, that probably the natural assumptions of those two things would have lead to thoughts of there being a third one. This would mean people would place more suspicions on others, thinking there were three groups and more baddies. With a for certian kill of one of their own..and pj possibly killing another one or Town (in which he'd say if/when he came out that he wasn't the one that killed the Alliance member)..that sets it up...but the third death of Hal throws a wrench into the plan. C2. Also, I think that there would have been explanations called out upon some members had Hal turned up dead. Like probably Cookies herself and the so called power she claimed to have since they seemed to be so similar. So anyway, that's my take on it all....after many hours of thinking on it. I have no idea if it's right or wrong or how close I am...but it's the only thing that makes sense to me, at least. The last question I thought, althought it's a small one, is D. Why Hockey? D1. She could have chose her just because she knew she anyone BUT River. D2. She could have chose her just to have another example to give Town the next day "Nope, Hockey isn't Mingo". D3. Could be a combo of D1 and D2. Or both at the same time that just happen to work out. So there you have it. As you see..my name isn't Idle Thoughts for nothin'.
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Nov 5, 2007 0:31:21 GMT -5
Just out of curiousity Idle Thoughts, did they say there were 3 x 50% doctors in the game or 3 x 50% pro-town doctors in the game. How many times do I have to say it? How much clearer can I get? THERE IS ANOTHER PRO TOWN DOC. He is basically ME only not me since half my powers were taken away. I was told, very specifically, he is exactly like me in all forms. Their powers are the same, their side is the same, their role will be the same. Please note, they can BE someone who already has a main role. This person DIDN'T BECOME a Doc. This person keeps their main role that they already are and only gained the 50 percent protecting power along with their original power. It is a TOWNIE. RANDOMLY CHOSEN TOWNIE. So I wouldn't expect to see anyone claim "50 percent Doc" because they are keeping their original role and only gaining the Doc power. So Inara (if still Town) could keep what he has but STILL HAVE the fifty percent power. Top Dog could have gained it and still would be Top Dog. The Crew Investigator could have gained it and still be the Crew Investigator and have the OTHER powers that go with this role. This isn't a change in role. It's an add on. A bonus. So it's not surprising to me that the person hasn't come forth yet. I'd think they'd want to hide it too because obviously coming forward would make them more of a threat to scum. Especailly if they have more than one power. Again, I have no idea who this person is...but I know, for a fact, they are in this game.
|
|
|
Post by CatInASuit on Nov 5, 2007 1:01:20 GMT -5
Just out of curiousity Idle Thoughts, did they say there were 3 x 50% doctors in the game or 3 x 50% pro-town doctors in the game. How many times do I have to say it? How much clearer can I get? THERE IS ANOTHER PRO TOWN DOC. He is basically ME only not me since half my powers were taken away. I was told, very specifically, he is exactly like me in all forms. Their powers are the same, their side is the same, their role will be the same. Please note, they can BE someone who already has a main role. This person DIDN'T BECOME a Doc. This person keeps their main role that they already are and only gained the 50 percent protecting power along with their original power. It is a TOWNIE. RANDOMLY CHOSEN TOWNIE. So I wouldn't expect to see anyone claim "50 percent Doc" because they are keeping their original role and only gaining the Doc power. So Inara (if still Town) could keep what he has but STILL HAVE the fifty percent power. Top Dog could have gained it and still would be Top Dog. The Crew Investigator could have gained it and still be the Crew Investigator and have the OTHER powers that go with this role. This isn't a change in role. It's an add on. A bonus. So it's not surprising to me that the person hasn't come forth yet. I'd think they'd want to hide it too because obviously coming forward would make them more of a threat to scum. Especailly if they have more than one power. Again, I have no idea who this person is...but I know, for a fact, they are in this game. Idle Thoughts: yes I know that there are 3 50% docs in the game. The question I asked was: When you were told about the 50% docs, were they in the game? or were they pro-town in the game? Please try and understand the subtle distinction between the two situations, because it means that either the town has 3 50% docs on its side or there is the possibilty that the scum has a 50% doc on its side. Think Carefully.
|
|
RoOsh
FGM
Former BatMod
[on:Wanna see a magic trick?][of:See You, Space Cowboy....]
Posts: 284
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by RoOsh on Nov 5, 2007 2:12:27 GMT -5
So....going by my three beliefs above...I would say that the two that most fit all three the best are: 1. Roosh (who was the first to claim on Day One, had a scum threatening role (one that had half a chance of killing someone who tried to kill him), and was put on the back burner by most the players here until recently). Well, Except when Ui tried to kill me on Day 3 or so... (-_-) And i'm totally understanding of the backup ability thing. As my role didn't indicate that I was a backup cop initially. It just stated my first ability, and hinted at something more. So i knew I needed to stay alive and that was it. It was only upon atarus's death did I realize what my purpose was. And just for clarities sake, on Day 1, i did point out that Recruits vs. me may be liable to my night action too. It wasn't clear, it just said hostile actions taken towards me would trigger the 50-50. So uh, I know that doesn't clear me or anything, but I can certainly tell you NOTHING has been told to me that my night action has been triggered or that I've been attacked/protected and attacked/ or recruited. But it's just something to keep in mind that I said on Day 1, and i'm sure no one would pay attention to. Unless they were a recruiter. But yeah, It ain't me. Currently, I'd like to focus on the SCUM, rather than the recruit. Because we have a pool of 3 to look at, and then if I stay alive, we can narrow down that pool further. If I die, maybe i'll take them down with me, or maybe at least you'll have a smaller pool though than today's 1 in 3 at least chance.
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Nov 5, 2007 2:24:09 GMT -5
But I've said it before, I thought, including in that post I just wrote out. If I didn't, then I'm sorry I didn't make it clear....but I did just right then.
And here it is again: YES, the third Doc who is at a fifty percent chance of protecting someone else or themselves is PRO-TOWN[/i][/u]. Fact. 100 percent surity.
|
|
RoOsh
FGM
Former BatMod
[on:Wanna see a magic trick?][of:See You, Space Cowboy....]
Posts: 284
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by RoOsh on Nov 5, 2007 3:04:58 GMT -5
I still wanna know who Nesta was looking for.... And if it had anything to do w/ a recruit or Zeriel, or Cat, or WTF....
|
|
|
Post by CatInASuit on Nov 5, 2007 6:15:49 GMT -5
But I've said it before, I thought, including in that post I just wrote out. If I didn't, then I'm sorry I didn't make it clear....but I did just right then. And here it is again: YES, the third Doc who is at a fifty percent chance of protecting someone else or themselves is PRO-TOWN[/i][/u]. Fact. 100 percent surity.[/quote] Damn Idle Thoughts, you sound evasive or maybe I am not explaining it clearly enough for you. We know that the person with half you powers is pro-town. I was not asking about them. You said that the mods told you there were now 3 people with 50% protect after your return. 1. Idle Thoughts = pro-town 2. The person with the other half of your powers = pro-town 3. Another 50% protecter - alignment unknown So to repeat the question, did the mods say that all 3 people with 50% protect were pro-town or just that there were 3 people with 50% protect in the game. Roosh: As for who nesta is looking for, I am betting it was Hal Briston.
|
|
RoOsh
FGM
Former BatMod
[on:Wanna see a magic trick?][of:See You, Space Cowboy....]
Posts: 284
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by RoOsh on Nov 5, 2007 6:52:04 GMT -5
Also, another reason I just thought of for the Targeting of Capt. Klutz:
-Scum KNEW there was a 2nd killer. With Greedy the SK gone, they still noticed bodies on Night 4 (2nd MultiKill night). So they could have devised said plan with two goals in mind perhaps: If they chose to KILL Klutz without killing anyone else, and the Vig killed, then they could create doubt perhaps. The Vig would be inclined to believe there was a 3rd killing group. Or one of them could then claim that he was a one-shot vig (as they didn't believe there were anymore cops around), and do basically what Hal has done (sorry for the suspicion Hal. I believe you for other reasons, but admit it, popping up out the blue ala Pygmy or someone and saying they're a one shot vig, would make them kinda townie). It'd be a great cover to create a "pro-town" player for them. -The other idea is this: By killing the Scum, the vig wonders if there IS a 3rd group... and the scum could also then hint that maybe a Recruitment had taken place. So if there wasn't a recruitment option GIVEN to the scum, or maybe they wanted to save it for later, they might have said this in hopes of having the Vig then wonder if he should hit PRO-TOWN players thinking they were recruits. Or maybe to create suspicion in that the next night they might figure out which specific person they wanted to recruit- because they COULD recruit possibly and still have a kill- If a recruiter did the recruit, and Cookies "investigated" Hal. Then hal could die and the Vig and rest of town would wake up and still see a "kill", while there was actually a recruit going on.
This is all WIFOM, but I think these could be reasons for killing Klutz.
|
|
|
Post by CatInASuit on Nov 5, 2007 9:13:59 GMT -5
So whatthefrak,
any comments on the fact I think you are scum?
And any reason for only posting 3 times in the last 3 weeks? You have less posts than DiggitCamara and he died on night 2.
|
|
|
Post by NAF1138 on Nov 5, 2007 11:28:08 GMT -5
WTF hasn't even logged on in over 5 days. When I poked him last time he said that he was going through a stressful work thing that was keeping him away. After all the subs we have already had I took pitty and didn't force him out.
But...I am going to force sub him now. I should have done it yesterDay.
IF anyone out there watching wants to sub in let me or Kat know.
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Nov 5, 2007 11:56:12 GMT -5
You said that the mods told you there were now 3 people with 50% protect after your return. Where did I say this? Can you quote it to me? Because they never said to me there were three people with fifty percent protection powers. I don't recall saying they did tell me that, either. They didn't say either. How does "is the third Doc [the one I'm talking about] pro-Town?" turn into "are there three Docs in the game?" You seem to have been asking the first earlier and now changed it to the latter. I have no idea. So far I've assumed there is three 50 percenages because WTF has claimed it and I'm not totally convinced she's lying.
|
|
|
Post by nesta on Nov 5, 2007 12:51:29 GMT -5
Roosh got my role right, or close enough to it. I suppose it could have been a good guess, but I'm inclined to believe that he's either what he says he is or that the scum have their own investigator. Another possibility is that panamajack snitched on me at some point. Time for my role-claim. I am Dr. Mathias. Role: Special Investigator Alignment: Crew For anyone very familiar with the show/movie, or as Google will reveal, my character was rather evil in the show since he is the doctor responsible for messing with River's brain. In the movie he is killed by the Operative. That's where my character in the game diverges from the show/movie. Apparently I survived the Operative's attempt to kill me, and didn't take kindly to it. I had a change of heart and decided I needed to find River and fix her. My special ability is to find River. I investigate someone every night and get back basically a yes/no on whether they are River. Also, since my PM had some vague wording about fixing her I've been assuming something else would happen if I found her. I haven't found her yet. I hadn't investigated Hal before he claimed, and I've investigated him the last three nights, but have not received a result. I wasn't surprised that Hal has the ability to hide because I had already figured something like that was going on. I was getting a little frustrated because my special ability seems a little less special since I know who River is but can't get a result. I can at least confirm that Hal is almost certainly telling the truth about hiding for the last three nights. I've been assuming that since there is something to fix that River is somehow broken right now. I thought one possible meaning of this is that she might not be aligned crew until I find her. Perhaps I'm wrong about this, and I don't expect Hal to admit it if that's the case, but that's why I was harping on him possibly being an SK type role. I thought once I found him he might turn into a Vig instead, but that seems less likely since panamajack turned out to be a Vig. In other words I really have no idea what my investigation would do to Hal, but I'm pretty sure it would be pro-town (or the Mods truly are bastards). One possibility that I've been thinking about since my second investigation of Hal was blocked, and therefore Hal was probably hiding, is that this might explain why Cookies wasn't planning on investigating Hal the night after he claimed. If she had already investigated him once or twice and received nothing back she might have decided it was likely it would fail again. It still doesn't make a whole lot of sense since her ability (like mine) was only useful on River, but it might explain why she was even considering investigating someone else. I'll be investigating Hal every night until one of us is dead or the game is over, so Hal whenever you want to come out of hiding and let me use my power that would be great.
|
|
|
Post by Zeriel on Nov 5, 2007 13:06:59 GMT -5
Good enough for me. Vote CatinaSuit
|
|
|
Post by CatInASuit on Nov 5, 2007 13:55:54 GMT -5
You said that the mods told you there were now 3 people with 50% protect after your return. Where did I say this? Can you quote it to me? Because they never said to me there were three people with fifty percent protection powers. I don't recall saying they did tell me that, either. From an earlier question about 50% docs from dotchan you replied with the following. Idle, are you sure that the mods told you there's a THIRD 50% Doctor? Yes. Umm, would you like to clarify Idle Thoughts?
|
|
|
Post by Hal Briston on Nov 5, 2007 14:00:55 GMT -5
Ok, catch-up time. Been a very busy extended weekend -- I'll read the day and give me thoughts in a bit.
|
|
RoOsh
FGM
Former BatMod
[on:Wanna see a magic trick?][of:See You, Space Cowboy....]
Posts: 284
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by RoOsh on Nov 5, 2007 14:12:10 GMT -5
Come on CatinaSuit.... I can understand Idle's points, can't you see what he's saying? Idle, can you see where CAT is coming from at least?
Cat- Idle said his power has been split into 2. So he knows he's a doc, and he knows that there is another pro-TOWN player out there who now has a 50% protect ability added on. Idle- Cat is saying he wants to know if you were told specifically the number of Doctors, or if you only know that your power was split. Ie: Did the MODS say that there were 3 doctors, or did the mods only tell you that your power was split into 50-50, and made no mention of WTF pretty much.
Cat, Idle has stated the 3rd doctor is pro-town. The only reason he stated 3rd, is because he, (and i, and perhaps the rest of us), are ASSUMING that WTF's claim means he's the 1st or 2nd doctor type role. That's why he's stating 3rd. But I doubt the mods specified to him if there became a 3rd doctor, or if the power was split. I see where you're coming from but right now I feel like you guys are circling each other, without asking the right Qs.
So there ya go. Idle- Did the mods mention/imply 3rd when they referred to the other person getting your powers? We understand that there is a 2nd doctor who has 50% of your abilities. But did the Mods refer to him as the 2nd one, or the 3rd one? <- this is cat's point that he keeps 'switching' on as you said. And Cat- I believe Idle has stated that he only knows about 2 doctors/can confirm only his own, and the fact that there is another. But I guess, Idle can clear that up.
|
|
|
Post by NAF1138 on Nov 5, 2007 14:18:22 GMT -5
ok, it's official. Mhaye will be taking over the role of WTF's character.
Everyone welcome back Mhaye.
|
|
Hockey Monkey!
Borogrove
This is supposed to be a happy occasion. Let's not bicker over who killed who.
Posts: 371
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by Hockey Monkey! on Nov 5, 2007 14:19:17 GMT -5
Roosh got my role right, or close enough to it. I suppose it could have been a good guess, but I'm inclined to believe that he's either what he says he is or that the scum have their own investigator. Another possibility is that panamajack snitched on me at some point. Time for my role-claim. I am Dr. Mathias. Role: Special Investigator Alignment: Crew For anyone very familiar with the show/movie, or as Google will reveal, my character was rather evil in the show since he is the doctor responsible for messing with River's brain. In the movie he is killed by the Operative. That's where my character in the game diverges from the show/movie. Apparently I survived the Operative's attempt to kill me, and didn't take kindly to it. I had a change of heart and decided I needed to find River and fix her. My special ability is to find River. I investigate someone every night and get back basically a yes/no on whether they are River. Also, since my PM had some vague wording about fixing her I've been assuming something else would happen if I found her. I haven't found her yet. I hadn't investigated Hal before he claimed, and I've investigated him the last three nights, but have not received a result. I wasn't surprised that Hal has the ability to hide because I had already figured something like that was going on. I was getting a little frustrated because my special ability seems a little less special since I know who River is but can't get a result. I can at least confirm that Hal is almost certainly telling the truth about hiding for the last three nights. I've been assuming that since there is something to fix that River is somehow broken right now. I thought one possible meaning of this is that she might not be aligned crew until I find her. Perhaps I'm wrong about this, and I don't expect Hal to admit it if that's the case, but that's why I was harping on him possibly being an SK type role. I thought once I found him he might turn into a Vig instead, but that seems less likely since panamajack turned out to be a Vig. In other words I really have no idea what my investigation would do to Hal, but I'm pretty sure it would be pro-town (or the Mods truly are bastards). One possibility that I've been thinking about since my second investigation of Hal was blocked, and therefore Hal was probably hiding, is that this might explain why Cookies wasn't planning on investigating Hal the night after he claimed. If she had already investigated him once or twice and received nothing back she might have decided it was likely it would fail again. It still doesn't make a whole lot of sense since her ability (like mine) was only useful on River, but it might explain why she was even considering investigating someone else. I'll be investigating Hal every night until one of us is dead or the game is over, so Hal whenever you want to come out of hiding and let me use my power that would be great. Am I the only one not looking for River? Seriously, though, this claim is making me look slightly askance at Hal now. I want to know what will happen when Nesta finds him. I know there are other fish to fry today, and I have no idea right now who to believe and who not to believe. Roosh and Nesta seem clean to me. Hal was on that list, but now not quite as clean. Of course Idle Thoughts is on there. Dotchan, I'm not quite sure of, but can leave thinking about for another day. So my choices today come down to CatInASuit, WhatTheFrak(or his replacement), and zerielV2. Quite frankly, I'm suspicious of all three to some extent. We have until tomorrow right? I'll get a vote in before the deadline, but don't wait on me if someone wants to hammer.
|
|
|
Post by CatInASuit on Nov 5, 2007 14:28:51 GMT -5
<turns pedant mode off> Yes, I can see Idle Thoughts POV. I shall leave it for another time. Hello again MHaye, so why shouldn't we lynch you ;D
|
|
|
Post by Hal Briston on Nov 5, 2007 14:45:59 GMT -5
Reading through the thread, my list of "most likely suspects" is the same as has already been mentioned -- CatinaSuit, WTFrack (now MHaye2) and Zeriel2. However, nesta, your claim is giving me pause. It's all very WIFOM, but I have no reason to trust what you say. I'm not at all familiar with the show, but as you say, yours was an evil character. Granted, that doesn't necessarily translate to being scum here, but I'm hesitant to be found by you. I have no indication that I'm in any way "broken", so I'm not sure what benefit the crew would gain by my being "fixed". Your description of your Role PM makes it clear you don't know exactly what effect finding me would bring. Of course, that's working under the assumption that you're not going to simply kill me. However, even if I did trust you, the scum now know me as an unkillable townie. Popping my head up to allow you to tinker with it would also give them a clear shot at removing it. Pardon me if I decline your "fixing" offer -- I like my head where it is.
|
|
RoOsh
FGM
Former BatMod
[on:Wanna see a magic trick?][of:See You, Space Cowboy....]
Posts: 284
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by RoOsh on Nov 5, 2007 14:46:00 GMT -5
Yeah Mhaye... didn't we lynch you already... You Survivor you... >: ) Come back for more, eh? Like Dotchan3.0.... j/k
You shall be called WhatTheHaye though. Any please... contribute. Help us out here.
|
|