|
Post by Idle Thoughts on May 19, 2012 14:13:28 GMT -5
Feel free to start talking about the three people you want to kill.
Remember to vote by listing three choices once you've decided.
You may change them if you want, but just unvote and vote for other ones before the deadline.
|
|
|
Post by lauriern on May 19, 2012 14:34:15 GMT -5
Holy Mackerel, Lianne. Saved at the last second and by a Townie. That was close! Wombat99 will probably be under suspicion now??
|
|
|
Post by Rich Beckman on May 19, 2012 15:46:46 GMT -5
I would like to begin by saying to liane that I am sorry I have gone after you as scum, but I feel like you left me no choice. Unless someone else steps up and acts even more like scum, I am afraid I will be advocating your lynching in Day Three as well.
Having said that, the Day Two vote could not have gone better (well, without lynching michellehunter).
I think we should seriously consider killing michelehunter while she still has no clue as to who to take with her (assuming she can really do that.)
Yes, she is suspected and got five votes, but Day One voting gave dizzymrslizzy and Pleonast six votes each. In Day Two there was only one vote cast for dizzy and zero for Pleonast. These suspicions do not always carry over.
There is the chance that a Doctor might protect Michelle, but hopefully any Doctor would consider that Michelle has protected herself with the threat to take someone with her.
There is also the argument that killing Michelle will make people think that the two people she suspects are town (though maybe she takes one of those two, taking the secret of the third to the grave and so only "confirming" one town.)
Beyond Michelle, I would like to try and get town that no one suspects are scum. My first pick for this is colby11. He does participate, albeit frugally, but he has not given off any scum tells (as far as I can see) and has not yet had anyone vote for him.
Mahaloth would be another good choice.
Kagemoto another.
Vote: Vote michellehunter vote Mahaloth vote Kagmoto
Opinions please!
|
|
|
Post by Rich Beckman on May 19, 2012 15:53:12 GMT -5
[green]When does Night Two end?[/green]
|
|
|
Post by lauriern on May 19, 2012 15:55:20 GMT -5
I agree about Michele Hunter. Two of the people she named are town & if she's being honest, we could get two-for-one by killing her. I know it is a risk not knowing who the third name is, but I think it's worth the risk.
I'm so not sure right now about the other two. I will re-read and think.
For now:
Vote: Michele Hunter
I will post the other 2 another time...
|
|
|
Post by lauriern on May 19, 2012 15:58:17 GMT -5
[green]When does Night Two end?[/green] On the other board, Chris said Night Two will end Monday, 3pm (AZ time).
|
|
|
Post by Rich Beckman on May 19, 2012 16:01:50 GMT -5
[green]When does Night Two end?[/green] On the other board, Chris said Night Two will end Monday, 3pm (AZ time). It is good that someone here can read with comprehension. Thanks!
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on May 19, 2012 18:21:09 GMT -5
Michele: 2 Mahaloth: 1 Kagemoto: 1
|
|
|
Post by cathi on May 19, 2012 18:30:18 GMT -5
Holy. Carp. Looks like I missed some drama! Off to read Day 2, I hope to be back in the game as of NOW.
|
|
|
Post by Rich Beckman on May 19, 2012 18:59:15 GMT -5
Holy. Carp. Looks like I missed some drama! Off to read Day 2, I hope to be back in the game as of NOW. Looking forward to your active participation!!
|
|
|
Post by lianne on May 19, 2012 19:03:33 GMT -5
Phew that was close! Richbeckman I understand that it is sometimes necessary to point out scummy behaviour in other scum although I have to admit that you did occasionally come back to me when the heat was going off me and going onto someone else which I could have done without! We are in the monority and we need to hang on to as many of us as possible and I don't think it is necessary to bus anyone yet.
I'm not sure about michelehunter I thought straight away that if her claim is true then her 3rd target was probably me and then wombat99 said that was what she thought too which would mean 1 town and 1 scum down if she goes. Not a good result. I think we should wait a bit longer on her.
The best people to kill now are the ones who are best at spotting Scum. Guiri has been right both times so far and is an experienced player with some good observations.
But what to do about all the people who are hardly participating? Should we get rid of a couple of them now while we have the chance? Hmm not sure.
For now Vote: Guiri
|
|
|
Post by lauriern on May 19, 2012 19:20:09 GMT -5
*bleached* Phew that was close! Richbeckman I understand that it is sometimes necessary to point out scummy behaviour in other scum although I have to admit that you did occasionally come back to me when the heat was going off me and going onto someone else which I could have done without! We are in the monority and we need to hang on to as many of us as possible and I don't think it is necessary to bus anyone yet. I'm not sure about michelehunter I thought straight away that if her claim is true then her 3rd target was probably me and then wombat99 said that was what she thought too which would mean 1 town and 1 scum down if she goes. Not a good result. I think we should wait a bit longer on her. The best people to kill now are the ones who are best at spotting Scum. Guiri has been right both times so far and is an experienced player with some good observations. But what to do about all the people who are hardly participating? Should we get rid of a couple of them now while we have the chance? Hmm not sure. For now Vote: Guiri [/color] [/quote] Guiri was one of the ones I was considering as well - he's not popping on the boards very often, but seems to pop in at just the right times..... Two others I'm considering are CatInASuit and Silver Jan because they both are making some astute observations. Still have more to read & may have more ideas.
|
|
|
Post by lauriern on May 19, 2012 19:37:05 GMT -5
Maybe Gadarene this time. I know I really fought this in Night 1, but I thought we could push town to vote him out. I never really found a good time to get something going in that direction though. ToNight might be a good time??
|
|
|
Post by cathi on May 19, 2012 19:57:35 GMT -5
I'm up to page 13, only 10 to go. So far, I have to agree that Guiri is on my list. And I'm just starting the crazy townie part, but michellehunter looks good too.... Lianne, I haven't gotten to the part where she's pointing your way.
I still think we can get Gad mislynched, we just have to get the ball rolling. Maybe we have a game plan of our own? A blueprint to guide the townies to lynch the way we want?
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on May 19, 2012 20:13:29 GMT -5
Michele: 2 Mahaloth: 1 Kagemoto: 1 Guiri: 1
|
|
|
Post by annem on May 19, 2012 20:21:23 GMT -5
I agree on michelehunter - if she is what she says we might as well remove her while it's still likely she'll take another Town with her. And stopping the discussion of what her role is would be a bonus.
Guiri seems to be asking good (dangerous) questions.
I'm not sure about a third, so I won't put in an official vote yet, but these are likely to be my first two choices when I do.
|
|
|
Post by Rich Beckman on May 19, 2012 20:25:19 GMT -5
I do not have a problem with killing Guiri.
Of my three votes, I would give up MichelleHunter.
Since I voted, a hunch was welled up in me that Mahaloth and Kagemoto are excellent candidates for power roles. They are definitely playing, but they are keeping their profile low.
Guiri would qualify for that, also.
|
|
|
Post by lauriern on May 19, 2012 20:37:39 GMT -5
Re-reading Day 2- Guiri is definitely making some good guesses...
Vote: guiri
|
|
|
Post by lauriern on May 19, 2012 21:14:43 GMT -5
Too tired to read anymore tonight - will come up with a third tomorrow. Definitely keeping Michele H. I think it's better to get her out of the way now. The further we go in this game, the higher the chance she will have a bead on one of us. I just hope her third isn't one of us already.
|
|
|
Post by cathi on May 19, 2012 21:32:26 GMT -5
What is a bomb? How does it work? There was speculation that michellehunter wasn't "just" a crazy townie, but a bomb of sorts?
|
|
|
Post by lianne on May 19, 2012 21:41:30 GMT -5
Any thoughts on how Lightfoot died team? She didn't seem to be much in evidence on Day 1 but then someone knew to kill her off...She was however hugely helpful in this thread - can there be any people here who are not real scum?
|
|
|
Post by Rich Beckman on May 19, 2012 22:06:12 GMT -5
Any thoughts on how Lightfoot died team? She didn't seem to be much in evidence on Day 1 but then someone knew to kill her off...She was however hugely helpful in this thread - can there be any people here who are not real scum? In the Welcome Scum thread Lightfoot posted: "there is a glitch in this board Which may get me killed" In the Day One thread, on May 9 at 5:50 pm, Lightfoot posted: "Now back to discussing who we all want to kill [grin]" A lot of players have pointed at the use of the word "kill" instead of lynch. Town lynches, scum kill. That early in the game, that is enough. The guess is a Vigilante killed her. I suspect that to be true, at least until further evidence comes along. Interestingly, on May 8 at 2:35 pm Lightfoot posted in the Day One thread: "Sure most of the time Town kill the wrong player because they don't know" A second (first) use of the word "kill". I do not believe that I have seen anyone point to this post, but the Vig might well have noticed it. All of Lightfoot's posts are here: idlemafia.com/index.cgi?action=userrecentposts&user=yeemumakaren
|
|
|
Post by Rich Beckman on May 19, 2012 22:08:22 GMT -5
Any thoughts on how Lightfoot died team? She didn't seem to be much in evidence on Day 1 but then someone knew to kill her off...She was however hugely helpful in this thread - can there be any people here who are not real scum? As I understand the game, only scum can get into the scum threads. Otherwise, Town would win every game.
|
|
|
Post by Rich Beckman on May 19, 2012 22:15:48 GMT -5
What is a bomb? How does it work? There was speculation that michellehunter wasn't "just" a crazy townie, but a bomb of sorts? From wikiguides.neoseeker.com/wiki/The%20Mafia%20Game/Bomb"The Bomb is a player that will kill his killer in retaliation. As opposed to the Paranoid Gun Owner, who kills anyone who targets him without repercussion, the bomb will only kill his attacker if he is killed; because the bomb's ability is activated by being killed, and not by being targeted, the effect can not stop a player from being killed. If killed at night, the bomb will kill whichever player's character was at the scene fulfilling the actual kill, removing that player/character form the game. If lynched, the bomb will most often kill the last player to vote for him or her, though a the first, second, third (and etc) player could also be used." Clearly, what Michelle claims to be and the bomb have a lot in common. Both result in the death of another player when the Crazy Townie or the Bomb are killed. The difference being that the crazy townie gets to choose who dies, whereas the Bomb kills by a set formula. The similarity no doubt led to someone talking about Michelle being a Bomb. Remember, we really have no idea what Michelle actually is. She could be vanilla, she could be a doctor, or a vigilante. My money says she is what she says and she will take someone with her if and when the time comes.
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on May 19, 2012 22:42:07 GMT -5
Michele: 2 Guiri: 2 Mahaloth: 1 Kagemoto: 1
|
|
|
Post by lianne on May 19, 2012 22:44:42 GMT -5
Ooh well spotted re Lightfoot's post in the Welcome Scum thread. Interestingly, the previous post to that by Lightfoot is one of only 2 where she signed on as lightfoot instead of Lightfoot. Could this have caused her to be spotted somehow? It was a very strange thing to post. Especially as it was on the scum board so she should have been able to explain more. Idle any clues?
|
|
|
Post by cathi on May 20, 2012 0:01:21 GMT -5
Okay, I want to get a vote down. I'm totally open to being persuaded, so feel free (as if you all need permission).
Vote: michellehunter guiri Archangel
I believe that IF michellehunter is a Crazy Townie, she is more likely to take another Townie with her now than later; if she's not, then she's still a Townie killed.
Guiri is spooking me with his picks; he's either picking up something everyone else is missing or he's really lucky. Either way, I don't want to worry about him any more.
I'm the least committed to voting for Archangel; just a vibe, nothing concrete.
I would like to vote for kagemoto, but I don't want to narrow down the scum-candidates from the mchelle71 mislynch voters.
As for Gadarene...in addition to the points I made last Night, he's now voted for two Townies to be mislynched. We can use this in our case against him.
|
|
|
Post by cathi on May 20, 2012 0:17:12 GMT -5
Night all, be back tomorrow.
|
|
|
Post by AmyKay on May 20, 2012 0:29:58 GMT -5
why didn't Town stay with their original hunches, like dizzymrslizzy, Pleonast, or Meeko? They all got big votes Day 1… what makes them less suspicious now? Or do they really just go off the most suspicious as time goes on? Similarly, why did hal keep his vote on lauriern?
If michelehunter does indeed have the ability to take someone down with her, I think it's in our best interest to knock her off ASAP. The longer she’s alive, the more chance she has of taking down a Scum with her, as she might get more hints. As it is, she may take down a town, which is what we want. As SilverJan said, it’s a no-win for town at this point regarding michelehunter’s “power.”
I agree that Guari is good, but I think killing him would end up killing everyone he suspected. I want to get rid of Meeko. He received some votes on Day One and Day Two, and of everyone who has voted for him, I believe I'm the only Scum to do so (on Day One), so no big triggers there. Honestly, I don't like him. It could be the way he plays, but I don't like reading his posts - they almost make me cry for other people. I know it's been said that you need a thick skin for this game, but he's too harsh for me. I pick catinasuit for the third, who clearly wants to hunt, but is barking up the wrong trees, so it shouldn't matter much. I'm pretty flexible on that third one, though.
So, I vote: michelehunter Meeko catinasuit
Any thoughts on who their second detective might have inquired about already? And, I didn't get to answer on Night One before time ran out - for those trying to keep track, I'm just plain scum, no special power.
|
|
Total Ullz
Administrator
You can take the girl out of mafia - but you can't take mafia out of the girl
Posts: 2,029
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Post by Total Ullz on May 20, 2012 1:40:55 GMT -5
1. Gadarene 2. Guiri 3. CatInASuit
Writing this in a hurry from the phone: All 3 are great players and has proven before to be great in this game. I personal think it's better to kill off townies hunting for scum than to keep them alive to build a case based on their voting. Because we all vote for town now and again. Also in a typically mafia-game the game will turn by Day 3. Scum will start of with information and Town with numbers. By Day 3 (in most games) town will start to see so much in actions and voting-patterns that they will start to vig/lynch Scum. This is also worth remembering about our Crazy Town. ToDay she didn't name Scum but she might in Days to come. So I also okay with us killing her off. lianne: It's a game and we win together. No bad feelings I hope
|
|