|
|
Post by Silver Jan on Jul 3, 2012 0:22:19 GMT -5
The only good thing about Gnarly' s death is that we can now totally trust his results, you will be missed though. Two of the people on his list I had a scum lean on so it looks as if I am going to have to work a bit harder toDay. It's very strange for me to be confirmed Town and still alive after all this time, I haven't had to defend myself, which is what I normally have to do in games and I think it's made me a bit lazy.
I think it would be handy if Hal gave us results on who he investigated last Night, just to make the places that scum could hide in just a bit smaller. Obviously that's up to him though, I wouldn't want to get another Townie killed just to make my life easier.
Patricia, do you intend to go after Meeko again?
Dizzy, I do hope you came back as Town because I don't know if I will be able to separate the new and old you, you were playing very well as Dizzy 1.
|
|
|
|
Post by CatInASuit on Jul 3, 2012 3:33:10 GMT -5
Updated, color-coded vote count. Probably inaccurate and missing some subs.  ---------- Day 1---------- starrirain_v1 (14): Archangel[97], colby11[109], Gadarene[175], septimus_v1[325], Pleonast[560], mchlle71[579], dizzymrslizzy[599], lianne[604], richardbeckman[624], supermel[648], jmj697mn[650], annem[651], ascime[652], laurieRn[669]dizzymrslizzy (6): SuburbanPlankton[65], wombat99_v1[198], SilverJan[332], Paranoia[404], cathi[581], starrirain_v1[596]Pleonast (6): CatInASuit[10], BillMc[13], Meeko[14], cassiepietz[117], michelehunter_v1[126], jmj697mn[142-308][/color], dizzymrslizzy[266-364], francescaj[329]Meeko (5): crys_v2[28], Pleonast[35-338], SilverJan[151-332], lauriern[199-669], amykb[203], septimus[206-325], patricia[225], crys[228], annetastic[240]SuburbanPlankton (2): Mahaloth[104], texcat[475]texcat (1): guiri_v1[243], jmj697mn[308-650]Guiri_v1 (1): dizzymrslizzy[77-266], SusanKMurphy[150] Archangel (1): oldred[154]cassiepietz (1): kagemoto[122], texcat[140-152]annetastic (1): colby_v2[244]michelehunter_v1 (1): Lightfoot[296]Lauriern (1): HalBriston[361]Gadarene (1): jerelijah[448] oldred (1): PhoenixPhyre[583]
gnarlycharlie (0): guiri_v1[9-243]wombat99_v1 (0): septimus_v1[136-206]catinasuit (0): Pleonast[338-560]jmj697mn (0): texcat[152-316]septimus_v1 (0): richbeckman[471-624]Not Voting (18): gnarlycharlie, SisterCoyote, jlrinmke, MHaye, laxrules017, wombat99_v2, Septimus_v2, endhoot, JustBeingGinger, TotalUlla, wombat99_v3, guiri_v2, colby11_v3, Michelehunter_v2, LadyRogue_v2, Starrirain_v2, Suits101, LadyRogue---------- Day 2---------- mchlle71 (9): wombat99[291-328,684], kagemoto[293], LaurieRn[294], richbeckman[297-300], Gadarene[318], amykb[327], annem[352], crys[414], jlrinmke[419], lianne[677]lianne (8): guiri_v1[143], TotalUllz[152], dizzymrslizzy[157], annestastic[400], septimus_v1[499], richbeckman[600], SusanKMurphy[614], gnarlycharlie[646]michelehunter_v1 (5): Archangel[8-534], jmj697mm[13], mahaloth[15], septimus_v1[319-499], wombat99[328-684], Meeko[370-386], CatInASuit[449], Archangel[633], MHaye[681]wombat99_v1 (5): supermel[417], phoenixphyre[496], Pleonast[456], Colby11[492], michelehunter[544]Archangel (2): cassipietz[74], lianne[75-254], mchlle71[105], phoenixphyre[133-496]Meeko (2): SuburbanPlankton[315], patricia[460] dizzymrslizzy (1): Pleonast[135-135], SilverJan[234-244,430-508,603], Archangel[567-633]Gadarene (1): Meeko[386], Archangel[540-567]Supermel (1): laxrules017[5]septimus_v1 (1): oldred[260] LaurieRn (1): HalBriston[398] wombat99_v3 (1): endhoot[556]endhoot (1): JustBeingGinger[606] oldred (0): Archangel[534-539]laxrules017 (0): Meeko[66-370], Colby11[85-492]cassiepietz (0): Gadarene[132-318], Pleonast[135-456]SilverJan (0): wombat99_v1[273-291]mahaloth (0): Pleonast[135-135]LadyRogue (0): SilverJan[508-603]Not Voting (17): Texcat, cathi, ascime, wombat99_v2, septimus_v2, crys_v2, wombat99_v3, colby_v2, guiri_v2, jerelijah, colby11_v3, LadyRogue_v2, starrirain_v2, michelehunter_v2, Suits101, Paranoia, LadyRogue---------- Day 3----------
Endhoot - detective reveal---------- Day 4---------- LadyRogue (9): dizzymrslizzy[26], SilverJan[42], cathi[110], Pleonast[157-157], kagemoto[169], Supermel[208], annem[210], wombat99_v3[228], richardbeckman[232], crys[236]Meeko (6): texcat[49], septimus_v2[54-106], mahaloth[55], patricia[128], Pleonast[157], amykb[168], MHaye[230]texcat (5): Guiri[4], Meeko[46], Suits101[73], septimus_v2[106], cassipietz[153] dizzymrslizzy (4): LadyRogue[112], wombat99[201], TotalUllz[206], michelehunter[226] Pleonast (1): oldred[59] wombat99 (1): SusanKMurphy[101] gnarlycharlie (1): Archangel[174] Annem (1): Starrirain[223] Non Voters (16): gnarlycharlie, SuburbanPlankton, CatInASuit, jlrinmke, phoenixphyre, annestastic, JustBeingGinger, crys_v2, jmj697mn, colby_v2, jerelijah, colby11_v3, HalBriston, LadyRogue_v2, starrirain, Paranoia ---------- Day 5---------- texcat (10): starrirain_v2[87], guiri_v2[89], septimus_v2[110], colby11_v2[173], Archangel[182], dizzymrslizzy[191], Pleonast[204], gnarlycharlie[209], jlrinmke[238], cathi[249] Pleonast(8): septimus_v2[6-39], Archangel[49-72], Meeko[54], richbeckman[98], Archangel[104-163], mahaloth[120], cassiepietz[135], michelehunter_v2[144], silverjan[246], texcat[252], crys[254]Meeko (3): mahaloth[9-120], patricia[75], Pleonast[83-204], annetastic[91], suburban Plankton[211], texcat[214-252]colby11_v2 (2): wombat99_v2[172], amykb[199] jlrinmke (2): annem[239], silverjan[240-246], Hal Briston[241]catinasuit (1): oldred[96]patricia (1): ladyrogue_v2[101] septimus_v2 (1): catinasuit[168]suburban plankton (1): supermel[215] crys (1): kagemoto[248]JustbeingGinger(0): colby 11_v2[3-173]starrirainv2 (0): Pleonast[23-83]Archangel (0): Silverjan[111-240]gnarlycharlie(0): kagemoto[187-187]Non Voters (10): phoenixphyre, JustBeingGinger, Total Ulla, crys_v2, wombat99_v3, Susanmurphy, jerelijah, colby11_v3,suits101, Paranoia ---------- Day 6----------
Annem - Detective reveal---------- Day 7---------- Pleonast - Detective reveal
---------- Day 8---------- jlrinmke(6): Hal Briston[14], annetastic[27], Silver Jan[38-108], cathi[41],cassiepietz[72], michelehunter_v2[82], patricia[111]Patricia(5): meeko[4], ladyrogue_v2[7], richbeckman[99], phoenixphyre[104], Silver Jan[108]crys_v2(3): Archangel[13], wombat99_v2[52], amykb[119]
cathi(3): starrirain_v2[55], crys[58], guiri_v2[122]michelehunter_v2(2): dizzymrslizzy[28], jlrinmke[85]Archangel (1): CatInASuit[45]Meeko(1): Suburban Plankton[67] JustBeingGinger(1): gnarlycharlie[100]Non Voters (10): JustBeingGinger, TotalUlla, crys_v2, wombat99_v3, susanmurphy, jerelijah, colby11_v3, suits101, Paranoia, supermel ---------- Day 9---------- Patricia(9): phoenixphyre[4], SilverJan[70], dizzymrslizzy[115], annetastic[121], Ladyrogue_v2[124], wombat99_v3[139], meeko[140], guiri_v2[142-148], JustBeingGinger[144], starrirain_v2[145] gnarlycharlie(6): Catinasuit[6], JustBeingGinger[17-144], Archangel [21], supermel[44], Suburban Plankton[113], patricia[125], amykb[133] cathi(3): crys_v2[123], guiri_v2[131-142,148], colby_v3[149] JustBeingGinger(1): gnarlycharlie[47]amykb(1): michelehunter_v2[98] Suburban Plankton (0): Meeko[3-140]richbeckman(0): guiri_v2 [11-131]Meeko(0): Suburban Plankton[18-113]annetastic(0): amykb[29-65], suits101[41-73]wombat99_v3(0): dizzymrslizzy[79-87]Non Voters (9): TotalUlla, susanmurphy, jerelijah, suits101, Paranoia, cassiepietz, cathi, richbeckman, Hal Briston |
|
|
|
Post by Suits101 on Jul 3, 2012 5:17:22 GMT -5
apologies for not voting earlier. or not participating more. in the middle of packing/moving AND working 7am to 6pm daily. still unsure who to vote for. i'm all caught up on the reading but it's all confusing. sorry to read Gnarly's been NKd though. i guess Hal's the only one who can confirm the rest of scum. if he investigates me, i'm just a poor vanilla townie anyway. wouldn't want a mislynch. so many of those. including patricia v1. i had a bad vibe about her, but then again i'm just another noob. Who's next on Hal's radar? Or anyone else for that matter? Why? I don't wanna jump on another wagon. Any scum results so far that you care to share, Hal? Idle, I don't suppose you can divulge how many scum/town are left hehe wishful thinking  Vote end day early - Idle, can we still do this even though there's no vote for a particular person? |
|
|
|
Post by wombat99 on Jul 3, 2012 9:36:12 GMT -5
Vote: Suits101 until a real explanation for the above is given? Yeah... wanting to end day with no lynch? The only thing that makes me hesitate is that it is just so screamingly, obviously, scummy that it can't possibly be for real. But - I already had Suits101 on my suspicious list due to subbing in after a 23-page Day1 when she should have had a feel for how much of a commitment this game would take, then lurking/being inactive. Suits, you say you aren't participating because you are moving and packing. Was that move unexpected? |
|
|
|
Post by Archangel on Jul 3, 2012 11:24:43 GMT -5
I'm sorry, Charlie, I had you pegged all wrong and I need to learn that for future games.
Vote Suburban Plankton for reasons given yesterday-- he's been hiding in plain sight and I think of the Charlie voters he's the most likely to have been scum.
I don't get the Suits101 comment so I'll reserve judgment until she answers.
Hal, I think your plan to hold your result for the time being is a good one but I think you should reveal the result before the end of toDay to make rock, paper, scissors fall a little more in town's favor than scum re protections.
|
|
|
|
Post by AmyKay on Jul 3, 2012 11:34:52 GMT -5
Ok, now we be a good opportunity for everyone to put down some thoughts on who they think is scummy, BEFORE Hal reveals any overnight readings. Let's try and get some extra details down for analysis. I agree. as a first-time player, I think one of the things that frustrates me the most is having a Day cut super-short. It's only happened a few times and all, but it's a very different dynamic. That said, Suits101 apparently feels exactly the opposite. But, for a lurker, less to read would be a plus, haha. Before I go voting for him/her, though, I'm going to finish looking at the histories of Cathi and Suburban, as I'm nt letting go of them from yesterDay quite yet. |
|
|
|
Post by Silver Jan on Jul 3, 2012 12:11:53 GMT -5
I think that when scum is found during an investigation it's great to end Day early, players get lazy and we all know who will be lynched anyway. I know there is a point of view that we can find more scum during that time but that almost never happens.
Now with Suits101 I am very confused, hasn't got a cooking clue who to vote for but votes for EOD, WTF, it's a good thing we need more than one vote to end the Day, unless........ s/he is the last scum??? I don't really believe that though, it would be too easy.
Vote Suits101
I definitely think an explanation is due there, it also makes me more comfortable that dizzy is still Town. I can't wrap my around voting for EOD without voting for scum. If Suits101 doesn't want to play then just quit.
|
|
...I for one will be sticking with the same person I voted the past 2 days unless something else comes to light.
I'm sorry, I'm not following your train of thought on why you think Suburban is scummy. Because of the vote on gnarlycharlie?