|
Day 11
Jul 14, 2012 18:53:46 GMT -5
Post by Idle Thoughts on Jul 14, 2012 18:53:46 GMT -5
It doesn't count. Day was over hours ago...Night coming now.
|
|
|
Day 11
Jul 15, 2012 8:09:12 GMT -5
Post by wombat99 on Jul 15, 2012 8:09:12 GMT -5
A comment from guiri to richIn retrospect, it was really her Day One conversion from anxious newbie to confident (but wrong) scum finder that turned me. What are your thoughts on Starrirain then? has made a light bulb go off for me. I would normally wait and post this Tomorrow, but I'm doing it now in case Hal has not submitted his investigation request yet, and he may want to investigate her Tonight. Starrirain has not been wrong, about anything, since her reincarnation on D3. I don't just mean that she's been lucky at picking scum; I mean that every time she mentions a player, her pings later turn out to be correct; her suspicions turn out to be correct; and her votes have been correct. In EVERY case where we now know that player's alignment, starrirain's been right. Every single one. If you look at any other confirmed Town's posts - even our best, most experienced players - it is normal to mislynch, to have incorrect pings, and to suspect players who later flip Town. There is no evidence of any doubt or indecisiveness in any of starrirain's posts, except in her D1 posts when she was mislynched as Town. I submit that it is not possible for any player, especially one in their first game, to be that good unless they are scum and have all of the knowledge. If starrirain is scum her pattern of being "correct" holds true, then Meeko is town, and richbeckman and amykb are scum. (There is more... I won't have a chance today to lay out a post-by-post case... and it's killing me! but go back and read starrirain's post chronologically. Note every time she mentions another player. You will see what I mean).
|
|