Day 16

[Idle Thoughts]

LadyRogue, TOWN, is dead.

Day ends TUESDAY at 11am.

[dizzymrslizzy]

Are we down to 10 players now?

[crys]

I think so. I hope there is more activity today from myself in.cluded

Sent from my SCH-I405 using ProBoards

[dizzymrslizzy]

Crys, we're 20% of the collective group! LOL. We almost have more participation than yesterDay.

So if the lone Scum didn't show up last Night, lets see who is MIA or has been. (I'm guessing only one person is scum at this point)

Last night only you (Crys, Myself, and Phoenix showed up)

So in the MIA pile are:
Meeko
Hal_V2
SuperMel
Patricia
Colby
Cassi
And Suits

Of those 7, Suits, Cassi, and Hal have been the most MIA.

I think Meeko, Patricia, Mel and Colby would have shown up if they were scum.

It looks like we have 3 days until LYLO from my estimation of 1 scum. So I'm going hunting in the real MIA pile. Unless someone has a better idea

[dizzymrslizzy]

It pains me to say what I said in Post 3, because I was really feeling Supermel as the last scum. He still may be, but after last nights events, I think Suits, Cassi, and Hal are better targets.

[LadyRogue-II]

Good luck town!!

[Colby11]

Updated list- Day 16

14. phoenixphyre
19. supermel
28. Meeko
33. Hal2
34. Crys
37. Dizzymrslizzy
40. cassipietz
45. Colby11
48. Archangel
56. Suits101
58. Patricia

Players left- 11

Killing Ladyrogue makes no sense, she hadn't been posting. If I was scum, I would have been going after people who were talking, like dizzy.

If we have 1 scum, Lynch or lose will occur in 4 days, fewer if we have more.

[dizzymrslizzy]

Colby, Idle said last night that if there was no vote then he'd randomly kill a player. I'd assume that's what happened, because like you said last nights kill makes no sense. I would have taken either one of the few active players or an experienced player.

[phoenixphyre]

dizzy that is a very good point, we have no way to know if that was a Scum choice or an Idle choice. One could think if it was an Idle choice that perhaps there is only one Scum left, and killing them would end the game. It is also possible that any Scum left are not active, so Idle made the choice for them? It just ads to the confusion I think. One of the long time actives could be Scum and a very good player, one of the experienced subs too, or one of the inactives. I really have no idea where to go at this point.

[michelehunter]

OCG:

I wanted to thank you all for your kind words and wishes, dad waited for me to return from my vacation and passed quietly in his sleep this morning. Thank you again for your understanding

[Colby11]

Aug 12, 2012 6:09:05 GMT -5 dizzymrslizzy said:

Colby, Idle said last night that if there was no vote then he'd randomly kill a player. I'd assume that's what happened, because like you said last nights kill makes no sense. I would have taken either one of the few active players or an experienced player.

I think that the game is wearing on Chris, he thought it was Night instead of Day.

But, which inactive to take out?

I say we just start shooting and leave the actives to fight it out

Meeko hasn't been around lately, so there's my vote right now

Vote Meeko

[JustBeingGinger]

Aug 12, 2012 12:21:34 GMT -5 michelehunter said:

OCG:

I wanted to thank you all for your kind words and wishes, dad waited for me to return from my vacation and passed quietly in his sleep this morning. Thank you again for your understanding

OOG: All my condolences! You're in my thoughts and prayers!

[patricia]

Michele - sorry for your loss - Condolences to you and the family

[patricia]

colby, thanks for the list and update.

you make good points I have felt Meeko was scum since the beginning but everyone else has town on him. at least the votes should prompt some posts.

Vote Meeko

[phoenixphyre]

michelehunter so sorry for your loss, you and your family are in my prayers.

[cassipietz]

Aug 11, 2012 22:38:57 GMT -5 dizzymrslizzy said:

Crys, we're 20% of the collective group! LOL. We almost have more participation than yesterDay.

So if the lone Scum didn't show up last Night, lets see who is MIA or has been. (I'm guessing only one person is scum at this point)

Last night only you (Crys, Myself, and Phoenix showed up)

So in the MIA pile are:
Meeko
Hal_V2
SuperMel
Patricia
Colby
Cassi
And Suits

Of those 7, Suits, Cassi, and Hal have been the most MIA.

I think Meeko, Patricia, Mel and Colby would have shown up if they were scum.

It looks like we have 3 days until LYLO from my estimation of 1 scum. So I'm going hunting in the real MIA pile. Unless someone has a better idea

I have explained my absence and I posted in the going to be away thread. I just got home today and have been reading what there is. I do not really see the "case" that was put out on Wombat that got her lynched which of course lands suspicion on those who voted for her. Something about this pings me and I just can't quite put my finger on what it is...

Aug 9, 2012 17:58:09 GMT -5 crys said:

I think that everyone may be on to something here. Wombat has pinged me a couple of times this reincarnation but I chalked it up to style differences. be forwarned that if wombat flips town I will be doing my best to build a case on one or more of the voters.

<Bleached>Wombat99

Not sure if it is the "be forewarned" or what but you happen to be one of those voters and I don't really think you will be building a case against yourself so someone's got to do it I also read the later post about your apprehension crys but I dunno...it doesn't sit right with me...if you really aren't comfortable with the vote...why place it? I think the apprehension coupled with sticking with the vote seems scummy to me. So, unless I pick up on something else...I am going to Vote crys

I dunno if there is one scum left or more than one but if crys is scum I sure would think about looking at the group from the first quote that she says thinks would have shown up of if they were scum...

[Idle Thoughts]

Meeko - 2 votes (Colby11, Patricia)
Crys - 1 vote (cassipietz)

[crys]

Aug 12, 2012 21:23:31 GMT -5 cassipietz said:

Aug 11, 2012 22:38:57 GMT -5 dizzymrslizzy said:

Crys, we're 20% of the collective group! LOL. We almost have more participation than yesterDay.

So if the lone Scum didn't show up last Night, lets see who is MIA or has been. (I'm guessing only one person is scum at this point)

Last night only you (Crys, Myself, and Phoenix showed up)

So in the MIA pile are:
Meeko
Hal_V2
SuperMel
Patricia
Colby
Cassi
And Suits

Of those 7, Suits, Cassi, and Hal have been the most MIA.

I think Meeko, Patricia, Mel and Colby would have shown up if they were scum.

It looks like we have 3 days until LYLO from my estimation of 1 scum. So I'm going hunting in the real MIA pile. Unless someone has a better idea

I have explained my absence and I posted in the going to be away thread. I just got home today and have been reading what there is. I do not really see the "case" that was put out on Wombat that got her lynched which of course lands suspicion on those who voted for her. Something about this pings me and I just can't quite put my finger on what it is...

Aug 9, 2012 17:58:09 GMT -5 crys said:

I think that everyone may be on to something here. Wombat has pinged me a couple of times this reincarnation but I chalked it up to style differences. be forwarned that if wombat flips town I will be doing my best to build a case on one or more of the voters.

<Bleached>Wombat99

Not sure if it is the "be forewarned" or what but you happen to be one of those voters and I don't really think you will be building a case against yourself so someone's got to do it I also read the later post about your apprehension crys but I dunno...it doesn't sit right with me...if you really aren't comfortable with the vote...why place it? I think the apprehension coupled with sticking with the vote seems scummy to me. So, unless I pick up on something else...I am going to Vote crys

I dunno if there is one scum left or more than one but if crys is scum I sure would think about looking at the group from the first quote that she says thinks would have shown up of if they were scum...

Uh huh and if you read everything I posted I put that I wasn't as sure of my vote as the others. However the problem with this game is that you can determine whatever you want if you are looking for specific things. I am town vote how you wish.

[crys]

Aug 11, 2012 22:40:44 GMT -5 dizzymrslizzy said:

It pains me to say what I said in Post 3, because I was really feeling Supermel as the last scum. He still may be, but after last nights events, I think Suits, Cassi, and Hal are better targets.

I would have to disagree here. I think that supermel is still a good bet. Supermel's participation although not steller, has become more active over the last couple of days. I have also been thinking supermel ever since the end of yesterday.

Vote: supermel

[crys]

Aug 12, 2012 21:23:31 GMT -5 cassipietz said:

Aug 11, 2012 22:38:57 GMT -5 dizzymrslizzy said:

Crys, we're 20% of the collective group! LOL. We almost have more participation than yesterDay.

So if the lone Scum didn't show up last Night, lets see who is MIA or has been. (I'm guessing only one person is scum at this point)

Last night only you (Crys, Myself, and Phoenix showed up)

So in the MIA pile are:
Meeko
Hal_V2
SuperMel
Patricia
Colby
Cassi
And Suits

Of those 7, Suits, Cassi, and Hal have been the most MIA.

I think Meeko, Patricia, Mel and Colby would have shown up if they were scum.

It looks like we have 3 days until LYLO from my estimation of 1 scum. So I'm going hunting in the real MIA pile. Unless someone has a better idea

I have explained my absence and I posted in the going to be away thread. I just got home today and have been reading what there is. I do not really see the "case" that was put out on Wombat that got her lynched which of course lands suspicion on those who voted for her. Something about this pings me and I just can't quite put my finger on what it is...

Aug 9, 2012 17:58:09 GMT -5 crys said:

I think that everyone may be on to something here. Wombat has pinged me a couple of times this reincarnation but I chalked it up to style differences. be forwarned that if wombat flips town I will be doing my best to build a case on one or more of the voters.

<Bleached>Wombat99

Not sure if it is the "be forewarned" or what but you happen to be one of those voters and I don't really think you will be building a case against yourself so someone's got to do it I also read the later post about your apprehension crys but I dunno...it doesn't sit right with me...if you really aren't comfortable with the vote...why place it? I think the apprehension coupled with sticking with the vote seems scummy to me. So, unless I pick up on something else...I am going to Vote crys

I dunno if there is one scum left or more than one but if crys is scum I sure would think about looking at the group from the first quote that she says thinks would have shown up of if they were scum...

And on the reread I never ever said I thought any of those players were scum.......another player posted that.

It was a forewarning. I will be looking, but my gut is saying supermel. It could be wrong, but the last time I had such a strong gut feeling it was Cathi and she flipped scum.

[supermel]

I think ladyrogue is a very odd choice by scum, i would think killing off a more vocal player would make more sense- i think idle killing off a random player could definetly be possible... so i'm wondering if scum is hiding in inactives. I don't think we have heard from suits101 in some days (I may be confused by subs) so my vote for now is vote suits101

[cassipietz]

Aug 12, 2012 22:13:21 GMT -5 crys said:

Aug 12, 2012 21:23:31 GMT -5 cassipietz said:

I have explained my absence and I posted in the going to be away thread. I just got home today and have been reading what there is. I do not really see the "case" that was put out on Wombat that got her lynched which of course lands suspicion on those who voted for her. Something about this pings me and I just can't quite put my finger on what it is...

Not sure if it is the "be forewarned" or what but you happen to be one of those voters and I don't really think you will be building a case against yourself so someone's got to do it I also read the later post about your apprehension crys but I dunno...it doesn't sit right with me...if you really aren't comfortable with the vote...why place it? I think the apprehension coupled with sticking with the vote seems scummy to me. So, unless I pick up on something else...I am going to Vote crys

I dunno if there is one scum left or more than one but if crys is scum I sure would think about looking at the group from the first quote that she says thinks would have shown up of if they were scum...

And on the reread I never ever said I thought any of those players were scum.......another player posted that.

It was a forewarning. I will be looking, but my gut is saying supermel. It could be wrong, but the last time I had such a strong gut feeling it was Cathi and she flipped scum.

Yes, sorry my mistake there...but my reason for my vote still stands

[crys]

Aug 13, 2012 7:53:29 GMT -5 cassipietz said:

Aug 12, 2012 22:13:21 GMT -5 crys said:

And on the reread I never ever said I thought any of those players were scum.......another player posted that.

It was a forewarning. I will be looking, but my gut is saying supermel. It could be wrong, but the last time I had such a strong gut feeling it was Cathi and she flipped scum.

Yes, sorry my mistake there...but my reason for my vote still stands

I'm ok with your vote. I can understand your reasoning even though it is wrong. I just wanted to point out that I wasn't pointing fingers at other players.

[dizzymrslizzy]

I'm changing my thoughts a little upon thinking about it some more.

There was only 1 killed in Night 14. So Scum had to have been around. Suits wasn't around at all (that we know of) so I don't think She's the final scum. I'm holding off any judgement on her for now, because I just think she's not showing up at all.

I'm back and forth here.

On one side Hal said on 8/10 (Day 15) that he'd be gone for the next 5 days. So he's really absent, and was absent for night. Could Reincarnate Hal be the "missing" Scum?

On the other side Supermel has done some shifty things the last few Days, like tip the vote onto Wombat on Day 15.

I'm going to go with my Gut for ToDay and say:

Vote: Supermel

[dizzymrslizzy]

And OOG: See Wombat I had a little time this morning, so I can work on digging through the remaining players!

[Meeko]

Vote Cassipietz

I don't think we have any more older players as scum. I don't think the kill pattern would be something experience scum would do.

Yes, there is some WIFOM here, but I don't think that the risk of WIFOM it makes up for the mistake that it is, leaving experienced players around.













Even if they do happen to more or less give up on the game. [Hey, if I'm lying here, call me out on it, but, yeah I did kinda drop off on this.]

[Meeko]

Aug 12, 2012 19:38:41 GMT -5 patricia said:

colby, thanks for the list and update.

you make good points I have felt Meeko was scum since the beginning but everyone else has town on him. at least the votes should prompt some posts.

Vote Meeko

Let's make an inactive player even more inactive.




Sure. Ok. Works for me.



I would be surprised if we have more than 2 scum left. I do not think that

33. Hal2
45. Colby11
48. Archangel

are scum.


I know I am not scum. But you know, whatever at this point.

[Meeko]

In my defense, after netting Pleonast [Damn, this game has taken forever] you would think that I would be more active, more free and loose with my play.

I just don't think that My actions leading up to Pleonast getting lynched, and my actions after, given the gamestate can reasonably conclude that I am scum.

[Meeko]

Aug 12, 2012 13:23:22 GMT -5 Colby11 said:

Aug 12, 2012 6:09:05 GMT -5 dizzymrslizzy said:

Colby, Idle said last night that if there was no vote then he'd randomly kill a player. I'd assume that's what happened, because like you said last nights kill makes no sense. I would have taken either one of the few active players or an experienced player.

I think that the game is wearing on Chris, he thought it was Night instead of Day.

But, which inactive to take out?

I say we just start shooting and leave the actives to fight it out

Meeko hasn't been around lately, so there's my vote right now

Why are you going after Inactives?

I thought the entire point of the game was to go after scum.

[Meeko]

FOS on Colby per "Lets Vote Inactives instead of Scum"