|
Post by Pleonast on Aug 1, 2010 9:51:49 GMT -5
Post summaries or whatnot here. Since you guys can post freely, you're free to post.
|
|
|
Post by Renata on Aug 5, 2010 8:56:55 GMT -5
01. moodymitchy 02. bufftabby -- CLAIM FREEMASON, not yet confirmed, unlikely witch (multiple reasons) 04. Pollux Oil 05. storyteller 06. eureka - CLAIM WITCH, very very likely true 08. BillMc 09. MentalGuy - CLAIM DETECTIVE, very very likely true 11. Honest Moley -- nphase thinks town, not witch (voted eureka) 12. Inner Stickler - ACCUSED WOLF, very very likely true 13. stanislaus -- CABAL 14. Captain Pinkies - ACCUSED VICAR, questionable (could also be wolf) 15. Mister Blockey -- harassed by wolves, town or undead, not witch (voted eureka) 16. Sister Coyote -- not witch (voted eureka) 17. Idle Thoughts - CABAL 18. septimus - CABAL 19. sachertorte - ACCUSED VAMP, unknown. not witch (voted eureka) 20. nphase - CABAL 21. FlyingCowOfDoom -- possible wolf (from stanislaus), not witch (voted eureka) 22. duvsie 23. redskeezix 24. Kat! -- probable town (harassed by special ed, comments make her unlikely undead). Not witch (voted eureka) 25. Nanook - CLAIM WITCH, very very likely true
The Dead: Special Ed: WOLF MHaye: very very likely town (MG's claim) Metallic Squink: possible freemason ("free" comment)
The following players are possible witches: moodymitchy pollux oil storyteller billmc duvsie redskeezix
There's now even more evidence that bufftabby may actually be a Vampire -- Squink's death. We "know" it wasn't the wolves, and we know that bufftabby noticed the post in which Squink probably breadcrumbed. Wish we'd get a confirmation or claim she lied so we can know.
Can one of you volunteer to do a search through day one's posts on the word "eureka" to see if anyone other than Nanook got antsy about the accusations or tried a little too hard to talk them down? I don't think I have time.
|
|
|
Post by Renata on Aug 5, 2010 9:22:02 GMT -5
Day One votes:
45, Moley, vote Eureka 57, nphase, vote bufftabby 74, metallic squink, vote nphase 93, mental guy, vote red skeezix 103, Stanislaus, vote Eureka 104, red skeezix, vote SisC 120, bufftabby, vote idle thoughts 142, mister blockey, vote sachertorte 148, mental guy, vote billMC, septimus, Eureka 155, sachertorte votes eureka 156, red skeezix votes bufftabby 157, septimus votes bufftabby 162, FCOD votes kat 164, sachertorte votes mister blockey 165, sisC votes mister blockey 167, Stanislaus votes special ed 170, mitchy votes mental guy 173, nphase votes sachertorte 178, nphase unvotes sachertorte 186, bufftabby votes nphase 187, sachertorte votes nphase 191, nphase votes septimus and special ed 201, idle thoughts votes FCOD, bufftabby, pollux oil 204, special ed votes eureka, septimus, bufftabby, blockey, inner sticker, duvsie, kat, Stanislaus 214, mister blockey votes sisC 220, kat votes septimus 224, mental guy votes mitchy, bufftabby, blockey 234, eureka votes idle thoughts, bufftabby 237, idle thoughts unvotes bufftabby, votes eureka 239, idle thoughts unvotes FCOD 240, kat votes eureka 241, idle thoughts self-votes 242, FCOD votes eureka 243, sisC votes eureka 249, special ed votes idle thoughts 251, special ed unvotes idle thoughts 252, mister blockey votes eureka 253, mhaye votes idle thoughts (his only good post of the day, as an aside. Too bad he’s almost certainly not scum, given mental guy’s reveal that he was killed by a wolf. His posts read very scummy to me, except for this one.) 254, nanook votes bufftabby (and claims for eureka) 256, ed unvotes eureka 260, moley unvotes eureka 262, duvsie votes hoopy frood (sigh) 264, Stanislaus votes duvsie 267, mental guy unvotes eureka 268, kat unvotes eureka 272, sachertorte unvotes eureka 284, fcod unvotes eureka, votes kat 285, bufftabby claims freemason 286, duvsie votes septimus 288, skeez unvotes bufftabby 292, Stanislaus unvotes duvsie 295, sisC unvotes bufftabby 297, sachertorte unvotes nphase 299 idle says lynch me. From here on I’ll only record votes that are *not* for Idle 311 septimus votes duvsie
|
|
|
Post by stanislaus on Aug 5, 2010 14:57:40 GMT -5
01. moodymitchy -- POSSIBLE WITCH (defended Eureka) 02. bufftabby -- CLAIM FREEMASON, not yet confirmed, unlikely witch (multiple reasons) 04. Pollux Oil 05. storyteller 06. eureka - CLAIM WITCH, very very likely true 08. BillMc 09. MentalGuy - CLAIM DETECTIVE, very very likely true 11. Honest Moley -- nphase thinks town, not witch (voted eureka) 12. Inner Stickler - ACCUSED WOLF, very very likely true 13. stanislaus -- CABAL 14. Captain Pinkies - ACCUSED VICAR, questionable (could also be wolf) 15. Mister Blockey -- harassed by wolves, town or undead, not witch (voted eureka) 16. Sister Coyote -- not witch (voted eureka) 17. Idle Thoughts - CABAL 18. septimus - 19. sachertorte - ACCUSED VAMP, unknown. not witch (voted eureka) 20. nphase - CABAL 21. FlyingCowOfDoom -- possible wolf (from stanislaus), not witch (voted eureka) 22. duvsie 23. redskeezix -- POSSIBLE WITCH (eureka followed his lead re sach's metagaming idea) 24. Kat! -- probable town (harassed by special ed, comments make her unlikely undead). Not witch (voted eureka) 25. Nanook - CLAIM WITCH, very very likely true
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Aug 12, 2010 15:48:16 GMT -5
People still alive:
01. moodymitchy 02. bufftabby CLAIMED 04. Pollux Oil 05. storyteller 08. BillMc 09. MentalGuy CLAIMED 11. Honest Moley 14. Captain Pinkies ACCUSED 15. Mister Blockey 16. Sister Coyote 17. Idle Thoughts CABAL 18. septimus 19. sachertorte ACCUSED 20. nphase CABAL 21. FlyingCowOfDoom 22. duvsie 23. redskeezix 24. Kat! 25. Nanook CLAIMED
Taking out the claimed people, the two accused of vamp and vicar, and us:
01. moodymitchy 04. Pollux Oil 05. storyteller 08. BillMc 11. Honest Moley 15. Mister Blockey 16. Sister Coyote 18. septimus 21. FlyingCowOfDoom 22. duvsie 23. redskeezix 24. Kat!
According to our list and what we know...there are still TWO Detectives in this mix, FIVE wolves, TWO vamps and a Necromancer. So, in total, EIGHT scum-like roles left. EIGHT out of TWELVE.
That means there are only FOUR people who are not scum left. FOUR people who could possibly be the TWO detectives and the ONE Seer...and then, of course, that means the last Town role must be the third WITCH.
So that makes me wonder...what happened to the third FREEMASON or the CORONER? Seems to me MHaye accounts for one of those (My guess is the CORONER)..so where's the third FREEMASON?
Anyway, back to what I was saying. EIGHT OF THE LAST TWELVE roles are scum roles.... Any guesses as to who is what?
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Aug 12, 2010 15:59:13 GMT -5
Strike that....my mistake. I took Sach off the second list as accused Vamp...that would make this list: 01. moodymitchy 04. Pollux Oil 05. storyteller 08. BillMc 11. Honest Moley 15. Mister Blockey 16. Sister Coyote 18. septimus 21. FlyingCowOfDoom 22. duvsie 23. redskeezix 24. Kat!
Having only SEVEN scummy roles in it somewhere. Five wolves, one vampire, and one necromancer.
So that leaves FIVE Town roles: Two Detectives, Seer, Witch, and Freemason who is not BuffTabby (Unless MHAYE was a freemason, then the CORONER is still in the game)
|
|
|
Post by Renata on Aug 12, 2010 19:27:46 GMT -5
Of those, I have tentative reads of Kat, Moley and Blockey as town, and a wild guess at Bill as a witch.
SisC and septimus are both potential wolves -- look at how Ed comments on them on day two. Though he's good enough to fake nerves where they don't belong, if you know what I mean, he still seems nervous. And more to the point septimus's semi-accusation against me on day three all but screams PIS from a wolf point of view. stanislaus had FCOD as a wolf.
pollux, story, skeez have all given generic scummy vibes (skeez has absolutely dropped off the face of the earth since day one, hasn't he? I know there hasn't been much to talk about, but still ...) at times, and duvsie's practically a no-show. If Skeez doesn't show up again in spades soon I'm going to read him as a spooked Undead, or as the Seer. Somebody with a damned important role, anyway.
That leaves moodymitchy as the only active participant in that list that I have absolutely no read on.
And btw about the Vicar -- Captain Pinkies hasn't posted *at all*, which makes Ed's claim on his behalf dubious. It could still be he's a wolf and the real vicar hasn't bothered to counterclaim with wolves on the docket each day anyway. So that might reduce numbers by one. Or MHaye could be the vicar.
As an aside, duvsie really should have had her list read Necromancernecromancerncecromancernecromancernecromancer .... Her playstyle is ideal. She'll sometimes get lynched on lack of participation, but very rarely before midgame, and she often makes it to the end. She's never night killed. Of course that's no reason to think she actually chose it, but she should have.
|
|