|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Jan 17, 2009 12:21:11 GMT -5
Everyone killed Sinjin.
Sinjin, A TOWN DOCTOR, is dead. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is now Night.
Everyone get your Night actions in, those who now have them.
Night will end..ohhh....TOMORROW at 8pm.
|
|
|
Post by Idle Thoughts on Jan 17, 2009 12:21:36 GMT -5
Or, it will end sooner, obviously, after I get all the Night actions in.
|
|
|
Post by ComeToTheDarkSideWeHaveCookies on Jan 17, 2009 12:27:08 GMT -5
Bye sinjin. I share your paranoia that something sinister is at work, but fuck if I know what it is.
|
|
|
Post by sinjin on Jan 17, 2009 12:32:03 GMT -5
Boo!
Love and kisses til we meet again;
Boo
|
|
|
Post by Høøpy Frøød on Jan 17, 2009 12:45:07 GMT -5
So we got two unconfirmed left.
Blockey and Cookies.
One of these is likely former/soon-to-be scum. One of these is unknown alignment.
Kat should spiny the one we decide to night kill. I'm going to look through Cookies history to see what I can find. I've already done an analysis of blockey, who I can add the last two Days to (since his activity has increased) and see which one I think is the better choice.
|
|
|
Post by Høøpy Frøød on Jan 17, 2009 12:55:39 GMT -5
The way I've seen it is mods won't end the game unless the losing side asks. Also, with the weirdness of the game, and the changeup of the roles, I don't think Idle would end it anyway. At least not until toMorrow.
But paranoia is never a bad thing in Mafia. Complacency is dangerous.
|
|
|
Post by Høøpy Frøød on Jan 17, 2009 18:23:19 GMT -5
So I'm back from errands. Looking at Day 1, I get nothing scummy from cookies. The only point I noted was that she and Sinjin had some cozy interchanges (and even voted one after the other for DBI). Now, at the time both of them voted, they brought DBI to tie with bufftabby at 4 votes each and about a day left in the Day. Seems a bit dangerous for either of them to do that to the scum godfather, because DBI could have become (and almost was in retrospect) an unstoppable train. It took Rugger's actions (which essentially outed him when DBI was revealed to be Wart) to derail the DBI choice and ensure bufftabby died.
The odd thing is, based on the numbers, one of them is/was scum. Sinjin is more apt to be scum based on that since she voted first when there still wasn't a tie. But unless there was some confusion among scum, their intent was not to bus the godfather, since Rugger pulled out his saving gambit. I have a hard time believing scum would cluster on something that could end up as a train. Day 1 seems pretty much a slightly town tell for Cookies and a slightly scum tell for Sinjin. (I included Sinjin because I did notice that they were very friendly in their interchanges with each other. Not that it indicates a whole lot since they come across as fairly friendly posters anyway.)
So yeah, on to the other days.
|
|
|
Post by Høøpy Frøød on Jan 17, 2009 19:09:02 GMT -5
Day 2/Night 2: Not much to go on here. Most stuff involved mmouse who was PFK. And there wasn't much in the line of tells from anyone. A lot of town pushed that train hard.
Day 3:
Says she'd like to give miteymouse the benefit of the doubt. Slightly town tell here since Rugger pushed miteymouse all the time. But it could be scum trying to separate themselves, so that's why it's only slight.
Votes DBI again as the second vote (which puts her in the lead since the other two candidates only have one vote each). Very early in the Day, so not a solid townie tell based on that, but she's consistently pressuring the godfather for two Days now, even if it is only because of lurking. That's gutsy for scum. The only pro-scum motive I can see is to get townie cred, but considering DBI almost died the previous Day, I'd think a scum would be a bit more wary of repeating the events again. Particularly when one scum already outed himself by his actions to stop it.
Comes under heat from Rugger due to her defense of Rugger's favorite townie target, MiteyMouse. And one of the few he didn't fling poo at was DBI. Once again, slightly townie tell.
Vote ends on DBI.
Day 4:
Agrees with me. STRONG TOWNIE TELL!!!!! (Okay, just kidding.)
Votes Ped. Null tell. Ped was coming up with horrible ideas.
Mentions that she's debating switching to DBI yet again (this was before the "my scum kills" thing).
After "my scum kills" slip, votes DBI.
Unvotes DBI to prevent early Day end. Doesn't revote, but the hammer falls from Chucara before her next post, so it doesn't matter.
Nothing scummy. Still getting townie leanings here. If she's scum, she's been doing a perfect job of hiding it so far.
Day 5
First one to mention that KidV is probably mason due to the time window of being able to fake claim after the modkill being very short.
Rest of Day 5 is her choosing between AH and Ed, voting Ed after I pushed that train and all the waffling that Ed did from it, and then trying to get Rugger after Rugger's claim. Nothing really to get here. Day 5 was weird for everyone.
Day 6
She outs Zeriel as contriving his PM. Now in my limited experience, it seems that Town are the type who usually out the 3rd parties through analysis, and Scum are the type that like to drive the lynch for them. So I count this as a slight town tell for her. Especially since after the train was running away on Zeriel, she was willing to step back in case we wanted to pursue the bomber instead. Scum knew he wasn't scum. They wanted him dead by lynch. The fact that she was willing to back off after I explained why we might not want to rush this, is a strong tell on the townie side.
Day 7
Not much to go on. Gets in a little disagreement with blockey, but blockey was going at it with Sinjin as well that day. Once again, I don't see much contention between Sinjin and Cookies. But personally, I think blockey was shooting for distancing himself as intentional strategy.
So that's the analysis. If I had another investigation in me, I would investigate Cookies, because I see nothing scummy about her. If she's scum, I give her Kudos, because I think she's played about perfectly as scum could based on what I see.
So yeah, I think our confirmed now scum should kill blockey, and our confirmed now spiny throwing Kat should spiny him.
|
|