Post by Hockey Monkey! on Aug 18, 2009 13:40:32 GMT -5
You're right HockeyMonkey, maybe I could have organized my post a little better.
My point is that on Day 3, you were sure that you found scum with Archangel. Yet, you didn't try to take her out on Night 3. You were so sure that you immediately voted Archangel on Day 4. But you never took your gunsights off Bill.
Then on Day 4:
Re: Day 4
« Reply #25 on Aug 7, 2009, 1:13pm »
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My win condition clearly states that all the Rebels must be dead. Dead, dead, dead. I'm clearly not interested in a peaceful resolution.
I'm also starting to think that BillMc is a peacekeeper. Not only him, but Archangel as well. I don't think she would have jailed Stanislaus (scum) if she were scum, and she claimed jailing him. I do believe she's the one jailing me on a nightly basis, but I can't ignore the color of my PM's. You guys can though. The color may have nothing at all to do with the alignment of the one jailing me. I'm beginning to think she's neither town nor scum aligned.
On the one hand, it's been good that I've been stopped from killing. On a personal level it's extremely frustrating. But that's why I claimed on day one - so that someone who could stop me could excercise their own judgement. Bah! I don't know what to think!
For now,
Unvote: Archangel
« Reply #25 on Aug 7, 2009, 1:13pm »
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
My win condition clearly states that all the Rebels must be dead. Dead, dead, dead. I'm clearly not interested in a peaceful resolution.
I'm also starting to think that BillMc is a peacekeeper. Not only him, but Archangel as well. I don't think she would have jailed Stanislaus (scum) if she were scum, and she claimed jailing him. I do believe she's the one jailing me on a nightly basis, but I can't ignore the color of my PM's. You guys can though. The color may have nothing at all to do with the alignment of the one jailing me. I'm beginning to think she's neither town nor scum aligned.
On the one hand, it's been good that I've been stopped from killing. On a personal level it's extremely frustrating. But that's why I claimed on day one - so that someone who could stop me could excercise their own judgement. Bah! I don't know what to think!
For now,
Unvote: Archangel
Your first reference to Bill as non-town in the whole game is that you're starting to think he's a peacemaker. Yet, you continued to target him instead of trying to kill rebels.
I don't have to kill any specific person. If I am a barrier to the town win condition, then I won't stand in the way of a win. Having them all dead would mean they aren't a threat anymore, so it looks to me like I can win with the town if we kill all scum. Bill's logic fails. I'm just a barrier to the Peacekeepers win and the Rebels win, so please don't lynch me today.
It looks like we have a definite target for today and a possible target for tonight if I am not blocked. I've been trying to kill Bill for 4 nights now based on one comment he made on day one. He was referring to NAF's question about be suiciding if it was good for the town. Bill said something to the effect of "Yes, THIS is the key question." It pinged me enough to try for the kill. Every day since my suspicion has only grown stronger.
I say we kill Bill today, then decide on appropriate course of action per his statements based on his death reveal.
Vote: BillMc
Your sights were set on Bill even though you were sure Archangel was scum and even though you thought Bill was a peacemaker. "I can win with town if we all kill scum." Is a false statement because you haven't even tried to kill scum.
Though you may have gotten lucky with Bill, I think you have your own agenda that you have not fully shared and are a danger to town.
I can see where you may be confused. When I said "starting to think Bill was a peacekeeper", that didn't mean "I 100% think Bill is a peacekeeper".
I had changed my mind about Archangel but the time it came to name a target. I always thought Bill was my best chance at killing a Rebel, and rather than shoot at someone I didn't have as good a read on, I stayed will Bill.
I have no agenda, no hidden win condition, you know everything. The way you are "interpreting" my actions is starting to ring scummy to me.