|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 10:31:30 GMT -5
Post by Renata on Oct 18, 2010 10:31:30 GMT -5
Initial thoughts -- Rajesh -- I have serious issues with your killing of Marcel, the fact that he was actually a townie being almost the least of it. You claim you feared redirection a reason to avoid targeting Dexter, but that rationalizes nothing, hence reads as false justification. There is no evidence whatsoever of a target-oriented redirector being around. None, zip, zero. As of yesterDay that was only a probability if Galadriel was telling the truth, which she wasn't. Not entirely true. Zedd has claimed to have been redirected. StayPuft likely was redirected. While Zedd isn't the most trusted source, it's possible that we do have multiple redirectors (maybe Scum and PFK) There's no evidence that the redirector isn't target oriented. That's what he said! I don't believe he's right, no I don't. Allow me to put on my professor voice. I even have the right sort of hair, heehee. We have the following three evidences of redirection. Stay-Puft from Dexter to Batman, night two (confirmed). Zedd from Corinthian to Skellington, night three. (unconfirmed) Dexter from Homicidal Maniac to Batman, night four. (unconfirmed) Nothing known from Night Five. Also, Galadriel from Zedd to Batman, night two (dubious). Gir from Corinthian to Batman, night two (dubious). This is quite easy to explain by means of a single traditional redirector, regardless whether Zedd and/or Dexter are telling the truth. Redirect the compulsive vig night two, then Zedd, then Dexter. Any of the latter two who are lying, the redirector simply didn't act (did the kill instead most likely), allowing them to take credit for being redirected as cover for their actual actions. Galadriel and Gir simply lied, knowing they could not adequately explain their presence, and hoped the the confusion would sow enough doubt to cover them. In option 2, all killers were redirected on night two -- this could coexist with a traditional redirector on Stay-Puft perhaps, but likely only if killer-director and traditional redirector are on different teams. If there is no traditional redirector active here, what does that imply for Zedd and Dexter? I think there must be a traditional redirector in the game (and on the scum team, if either is scum), else their claims are just ridiculously dangerous. That makes the killer-redirector rather optional from my viewpoint (I've never believed that Gir or Galadriel would NOT be willing to be caught lying as opposed to admitting a presence they could not account for; also, Galadriel may not have been trying to kill), but anyway, moving on. A target redirector: We have one confirmed target (Dexter), two claimed but unproven (Corinthian and Homicidal Maniac), and two dubious (Corinthian and Zedd). Of those, no scum or PFK redirector is wasting their time turning things *away* from the Corinthian. No way, no how. The other three are plausible, but two were on the same night, and it's rather a long shot at that that any target-oriented redirector would get two hits, on two different people, out of three nights. And it doesn't explain Zedd's redirection -- that would have to be something else. It's a Hood-damned mess, contemplating target-redirection, is what it is. I do not believe you could have taken the threat seriously enough to influence you to shoot for the guy who apparently only you suspected over the guy who half the town voted for the previous day.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 10:51:43 GMT -5
Post by Renata on Oct 18, 2010 10:51:43 GMT -5
Zedd -- convenient, that's all I'll say about that right now. The runner up for yesterday's lynch is thoroughly accused by the town cop and there you are right sharp to back it up. Why is it that everything you do, including your first accusation of a non-town threat, feels so false? At this point I can't even justify it with logic anymore, that's all been done pages and pages ago. Feels false? Why does it feel false? What kind of question is that? I can't control your feelings about what I say. And no, it was not justified with logic pages ago. It was justified with suspicious feelings....yep, more feelings. Try the other one, Zeddicus. It's got bells on. 1. Everything Corinthian, Rajesh, and I pointed out about your role claim and the issues with it, starting on day two and continuing off and on since then. 2. Your choices of targets. -- Batman. Not a great choice from a town standpoint; this was pointed out. -- Corinthian. Despite the discussion from the previous day, this choice is even worse. Plus, you claim but cannot prove redirection to Skellington, for which there are multiple potential scum motivations, beginning with not having to "confirm" the masons. -- Elizabeth Bathory. Your first good choice, but only after getting yelled at for the first two. -- Dexter. Comes conveniently right after the accepted town cop has made a thorough case against him, and in the context of massive town suspicion. I can't see this investigation result as a point in your favor, even if Dexter flips scum. 3. A couple Days back when the vote sat at 2 for you and 1 or 2 for a bunch of other people for days, when much of the discussion revolved around you and you were ubiquitous throughout the thread discussing yourself, yet never made an accusation. I think you finally wound up chucking a vote on Gir. 4. This post right here, attempting to dismiss Days' worth of frustrating pounding my head against a wall trying to get people to listen, and being dismissed essentially purely because "he made a counterclaim, scum would NEVER do that", as being nothing more than 'feelings'. Feelings, my mule's hind end.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 11:17:23 GMT -5
Post by special on Oct 18, 2010 11:17:23 GMT -5
Of those, no scum or PFK redirector is wasting their time turning things *away* from the Corinthian. No way, no how. No way a Scum or PFK would redirect things away from Corinthian? Even if the Scum felt it possible that Corinthian is: 1) Likely to be targeted by a protector. 2) Unlikely to be targeted by an investigator. Seems a prime use for a bus driving PFK or Scum. Especially now given a hint that PFKs may be coordinating their actions in some sense.
|
|
Natlaw
Snark
Natlaw is a Modron short and stout.
Posts: 740
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 13:19:59 GMT -5
Post by Natlaw on Oct 18, 2010 13:19:59 GMT -5
|
|
Natlaw
Snark
Natlaw is a Modron short and stout.
Posts: 740
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 13:36:32 GMT -5
Post by Natlaw on Oct 18, 2010 13:36:32 GMT -5
Day One: Maniac: George [8-325] Meeko: Eleanor [19-26], Marcel [68-119], Eleanor [194-221] Marcel: Eleanor [26-88], Stay Puft [230-291], Gir! [340], Death of Rats [437] Nakor: Corinthian [141-434] Rorschach: Rajesh [161-300] Stay Puft: Strangelove [233-391], Marcel [235], Nordom [289-383], Rorschach [311], Buddy Christ [315], Zedd [319-425], Rajesh [321], Dexter [375] Eleanor: Maniac [248-270], Iskaral [258-277], Death of Rats [265-267] Iskaral: Stay Puft [291-406], Rajesh [300-321], Skellington [308], Columbo [309-398], Nakor [313], Eleanor [415] Batman: Iskaral [320-396] Fangirl: George [325], (extra vote) [371], Nordom [383], Strangelove [391], Iskaral [396], Stay Puft [406], Columbo [410], Batman [414], Zedd [425], Corinthian [434] Joe/Elizabeth: Death of Rats [342-378] Death of Rats: Galadriel [369] Dexter: Columbo [398-410]
Not voting (3): Joe/Elizabeth, Fangirl, La Duquesa/Narrator
266: Eleanor claims doctor 323: Stay Puft claims compulsive vigilante 423: George claims mason
Day Two: Stay Puft: Rajesh [37-376], Death of Rats [39-241], Buddy Christ [45], Meeko [52-76], Marcel [77-162] Batman: Iskaral [50-319], Stay Puft [287-437], Zedd [347] Gir!: Eleanor [96-99] Maniac: Nordom [133-329], George [303-332], Iskaral [460] Marcel: Corinthian [160-250], Marcel [162-408], Meeko [168-237], Rorschach [171-420], Skellington [175-411], Zedd [346-347] Iskaral: Eleanor [187-359], Batman [281-536] Rajesh: Meeko [237-510], Strangelove [471-513] Corinthian: Columbo [251-450], Nakor [407-414], Skellington [411-444] Columbo: Corinthian [261-393], Maniac [299], George [332-502] Zedd: Gir! [265-354], Corinthian [393-511] Gir!: Galadriel [278-290], Eleanor [359-531] Death of Rats: Galadriel [290] Narrator: (extra vote) [295], Rajesh [479], George [502], Nordom [504], Stay Puft [506-530], Meeko [510], Corinthian [511], Strangelove [513], Eleanor [531], Marcel [535], Batman [536], Dexter [539], Elizabeth [541] Strangelove: Nordom [337-480], Rajesh [376-479], Stay Puft [464-485], Narrator [469-515] Elizabeth: Skellington [444], Nakor [526], Narrator [529], Stay Puft [530]
Not voting: Rorschach, Gir!
37: Rajesh claims vigilante with diminshing returns 183: Marcel claims single shot mass role block 289: Batman claims cop (later role + alignment) 347: Zedd claim investigator (either threat-to-town or powers) 413: Corinthian claims mason 450: Columbo claims role blocker 471: Strangelove claims mason 580: Maniac claims booster/inventor
Day Three: Almost all vote Buddy Christ (extra vote on Meeko/Paul).
Day Four: George: Marcel [27] Zedd: George [37], Rajesh [53-275], Meeko [63-321], Iskaral [75-316] Maniac: Batman [85-189], Iskaral [324-327] Iskaral: Maniac [145-313] Gir!: Batman [189], Nordom [284], Rorschach [306], Maniac [313], Iskaral [316-324], Meeko [321], Iskaral [327], Elizabeth [331], Nakor [336], Rajesh [362], Strangelove [364], Zedd [366], Dexter [369] Elizabeth: Rajesh [281-362], Death of Rats [287], Corinthian [288], Zedd [294-366], (extra vote) [317] Rorschach: Skellington [309], Gir! [350]
Not voting: Galadriel (jailed)
329: Gir! claim (Anti)Catalyst
Day Five: Death of Rats: Corinthian [1-60], Galadriel [45-93] Zedd: Dexter [4-15], Death of Rats [29-42], Iskaral [166-190] Galadriel: Maniac [12], Elizabeth [148], Nakor [177], Dexter [188], Iskaral [190], Nordom [192], Death of Rats [193], Meeko [198-204-206], Rajesh [200], Corinthian [205], George [216] Dexter: Nordom [50-124], Rajesh [59-200], Corinthian [60-205], Death of Rats [64-193], Iskaral [67-95], Skellington [83], Galadriel [93], George [99-216], (extra vote) [100], Zedd [110], Strangelove [155] Rajesh: Marcel [73-132] Skellington: Dexter [101-188], Iskaral [146-166]
178: Galadriel claim power hider
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 13:50:22 GMT -5
Post by special on Oct 18, 2010 13:50:22 GMT -5
Yes, I expected more questions from him. I expected him to question the answers he got more as well. I expected the questions to be more pointed about who did what action and why. I didn't expect such general questions that didn't apply to this game in particular. I expected more posts from him that questioned the goings on. maybe my interpretation was incorrect. maybe he was asking as many questions and I just wasn't seeing them. I guess he was just posting less than he usually does. He did the same thing in Colorless. He has claimed to be against bussing in almost any situation. He voted for a vig believing he was Town. He voted for a claimed Mason. On day 3, with the votes for Christ, he misrepresented that the masons were of the mindset that Christ was Town. I just saw Scum Meeko playing the way I would expect him to by not being willing to give up a teammate and when forced to, to try to play it to his teams advantage.
|
|
timmy
Mome Rath
In the frozen land of Nador they were forced to eat Robin's minstrels. And there was much rejoicing
Posts: 189
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 18:49:18 GMT -5
Post by timmy on Oct 18, 2010 18:49:18 GMT -5
Rorschach's Journal Day Six Spent last 36 hours being interrogated by forces outside of this game. Released early morning, crawled home to sleep it off. Feeling better now.
See Caped Crusader got out unscathed. Good. Learn he has information on players. Good.
Find out someone killed a Mime last Night. The Dr Vig claims responsibility. Hurm. Doesn't make sense. Mime posed minimal threat to Town, posed more of a numerical disadvantage to Scum. Second time Dr Vig killed Town. Very suspicious.
Batman investigates Dex, reveals Scum. Not going to challenge that assumption. If Dex not Scum, makes me wonder about choices for Jailing. Night 2, jails claimed Doctor, says to protect her. Perfect opportunity for Scum to get Doc out of picture. Night 3, jails Scum Total. Why jail one of their own? Night 4, jails Batcop. Again, another claimed Town. Last Night, jails Jack, claimed Town. Understands that jail ability is compulsory, Dex claims using it to protect. Apparently it allows for Night actions, good for Town. Hurm. Makes me think Dex might be Town, but with a handicap. I understand handicaps, only too well.
Zedd reveals Dex is threat. After Batcop reveals same information. Ehh. Thinking Zedd, like Dex and Dr Vig, not on same page as Town. But not ready to call them Scum, could be handicaps of all three make them look Scummy. I understand handicaps, only too well.
One Mason down. Sorry to hear that. Corinthian most informative of Masons, had good ability to read Scum. Up to others to fill in his absence.
Rats is PFK. Not sure how to handle this. First instinct, kill all threats to Town. PFK is threat. Batcop says lynch would be useless. Fair enough, will leave that one alone. Hope that is last PFK but all signs point to no, or maybe not. Could be PFK Team to equal Scum Team in size. Hurm. PFK Team. Name sounds incongruous. Like calling a bunch of Anarchists a Team. PFKs work alone by definition. Maybe what Scum Buddy said while climbing scaffold. First reaction, don't believe Scum liars. Maybe he wasn't lying.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 18:58:50 GMT -5
Post by special on Oct 18, 2010 18:58:50 GMT -5
[ Batman investigates Dex, reveals Scum. *snip* Zedd reveals Dex is threat. After Batcop reveals same information. Ehh. Thinking Zedd, like Dex and Dr Vig, not on same page as Town. But not ready to call them Scum, could be handicaps of all three make them look Scummy. I understand handicaps, only too well. Batman didn't investigate Dexter. He investigated Rats
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 23:00:47 GMT -5
Post by ComeToTheDarkSideWeHaveCookies on Oct 18, 2010 23:00:47 GMT -5
I honestly don't know what to think about Ed's killing of the mime. It is boneheaded, no doubt, but then so was the Mime's voting of Ed while he was still alive. Boneheaded + killing role does not necessarily = less boneheadedness.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 18, 2010 23:03:02 GMT -5
Post by ComeToTheDarkSideWeHaveCookies on Oct 18, 2010 23:03:02 GMT -5
And that's coming from a bonehead for whom The Corinthian had to turn up dead and Townie to set aside suspicion of the masonry. It takes one to know one.
|
|
Natlaw
Snark
Natlaw is a Modron short and stout.
Posts: 740
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 5:35:08 GMT -5
Post by Natlaw on Oct 19, 2010 5:35:08 GMT -5
Rorschach's Journal Day SixSpent last 36 hours being interrogated by forces outside of this game. Released early morning, crawled home to sleep it off. Feeling better now. What do you mean with 'forces outside of this game'? That it was a post restriction punishment? 36 hours means Night 4 + Day 5 + Night 5? Where you blocked from taking actions (dawn color only says speak + vote)? I honestly don't know what to think about Ed's killing of the mime. It is boneheaded, no doubt, but then so was the Mime's voting of Ed while he was still alive. Boneheaded + killing role does not necessarily = less boneheadedness. But Rajesh didn't give the argument that Marcels voting was bad and a liability as a reason. He has now said the votes would be very convenient for scum (which is true as they lack accountability). I'm not convinced though that Rajesh is scum based on it but it starts adding up (but could also be PFK). Same reason with why I'm not too thrilled with Zedd's investigation choice. If he's town I rather have him generate information on players that with a better chance to make it to the end game. And whether Dexter flips PFK (I'm speculating maybe a mad bomber in that case) or scum then Zedd can still be the opposite.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 6:39:58 GMT -5
Post by special on Oct 19, 2010 6:39:58 GMT -5
But Rajesh didn't give the argument that Marcels voting was bad and a liability as a reason. He has now said the votes would be very convenient for scum (which is true as they lack accountability). His voting pattern was certainly a consideration when I decided to try to kill him. It helped me consider the possibility of him being Scum. I didn't make any arguments about him because all of that went on inside my head. I wasn't about to share arguments about who to Vig with the Scum.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 8:19:58 GMT -5
Post by peekercpa on Oct 19, 2010 8:19:58 GMT -5
And that's coming from a bonehead for whom The Corinthian had to turn up dead and Townie to set aside suspicion of the masonry. It takes one to know one. don't feel too bad. i called him an idiot. talk about the pot commenting about the kettle.
|
|
timmy
Mome Rath
In the frozen land of Nador they were forced to eat Robin's minstrels. And there was much rejoicing
Posts: 189
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 8:26:34 GMT -5
Post by timmy on Oct 19, 2010 8:26:34 GMT -5
Rorschach's Journal Day SixSpent last 36 hours being interrogated by forces outside of this game. Released early morning, crawled home to sleep it off. Feeling better now. What do you mean with 'forces outside of this game'? That it was a post restriction punishment? 36 hours means Night 4 + Day 5 + Night 5? Where you blocked from taking actions (dawn color only says speak + vote)? Not 36 hours game time, should read 24 hours. Blame my clock. Was interrogated from Dawn 5 through Night 5. Could not get out until Dawn 6. Forces outside of game, not anyone involved in game. Not Scum, not Town, not 3rd Party. Forces outside of game did interrogation. Only post restriction was silence during time of interrogation. Was not jailed, like Batman. Interrogation only meant for me, no one else.
|
|
timmy
Mome Rath
In the frozen land of Nador they were forced to eat Robin's minstrels. And there was much rejoicing
Posts: 189
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 8:36:02 GMT -5
Post by timmy on Oct 19, 2010 8:36:02 GMT -5
Situation with Dr Raj troubling. Claims limited killing ability with diminishing returns. Killed two players in game, both are dead. See no diminishing returns. StayPuft had to kill every Night, said it was compulsory. Dex says has to Jail every Night, says compulsory. Zedd gets reading from clouds, learns of threat to Town. Large margin for error in that.
Sorry for wandering, mind does that. Point is certain players have handicaps. Abilities not infallible. Dr Raj claims limited ability to kill, with diminishing returns. Returns, or results? So far, he's been able to kill with 100% results. Two players dead. Both Town. Where are diminishing returns?
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 8:56:08 GMT -5
Post by peekercpa on Oct 19, 2010 8:56:08 GMT -5
vote dexter
if nothing else just to get rid of either a bad guy or confirm that zed is full of it.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 9:47:19 GMT -5
Post by Mahaloth on Oct 19, 2010 9:47:19 GMT -5
If Dexter turns out not to be a threat to Town, go ahead and night kill me to save Town from having to lynch me tomorrow.
Besides, if Dexter is not a threat to Town, my power is not worth keeping in the game, really.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 10:50:09 GMT -5
Post by peekercpa on Oct 19, 2010 10:50:09 GMT -5
If Dexter turns out not to be a threat to Town, go ahead and night kill me to save Town from having to lynch me tomorrow. Besides, if Dexter is not a threat to Town, my power is not worth keeping in the game, really. and in the interest of not reinventing the wheel. i believe iskral has basically said what i was going to say. your investigative choices have not been real remarkable and the conclusions/results even less so. and you do what you need to do, but certainly you can see how it looks if you were trying to spin it in a poor, or at least other than stellar, light.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 11:00:47 GMT -5
Post by peekercpa on Oct 19, 2010 11:00:47 GMT -5
and one other thing that has been gnawing at me a bit.
it seems like there is a semi general agreement that there was a mass redirect of killers to batty on the night of the party, right?
and i don't believe a thing that pfks or scum say about what happened, so there is that caveat.
well i can certainly see how puffy got redirected there.
gir could very well have been there on her on volition. i mean no redirection was needed to have an sk want to take out a claimed investigator.
maniac has said why he was there. while i don't give him a pass it at least makes sense.
ror was there and admits it.
galadriel was there and denied it.
so i can certainly see a scenario where a pfk redirected puffy, gir acted on her own and scum sent galadriel there to do their wet work. especially if scum have jailed a most likely doc at the time. and maniac and ror were there for their own purposes.
so i don't see where a mass redirect of killers is necessarily true. i don't know what it means but the monkey had some free time.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 11:55:01 GMT -5
Post by BillMc on Oct 19, 2010 11:55:01 GMT -5
so i can certainly see a scenario where a pfk redirected puffy, gir acted on her own and scum sent galadriel there to do their wet work. especially if scum have jailed a most likely doc at the time. and maniac and ror were there for their own purposes. so i don't see where a mass redirect of killers is necessarily true. i don't know what it means but the monkey had some free time. it doesn't seem likely/plausible that gir and galadriel would both choose me - someone who was likely to be protected and/or watched -- and indeed both it would be a very bad play on their part
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 12:08:24 GMT -5
Post by peekercpa on Oct 19, 2010 12:08:24 GMT -5
but bat it is apparant that both of them were there.
the fact that neither fessed up to it makes me confused.
what i was trying to get at was that it makes no sense for scum to redirect puffy there and then send a scum investigator.
i guess in my monkey brain what i was wondering is if there is a pfk redirector that sent puffy there. gir acted on her own. scum sent galadriel while dex was jailing our doc. in which case that is only one redirect of a killer and not this mass redirect killer thingamabob.
not that it proves shit one way or another.
|
|
Natlaw
Snark
Natlaw is a Modron short and stout.
Posts: 740
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 13:26:44 GMT -5
Post by Natlaw on Oct 19, 2010 13:26:44 GMT -5
Why would scum send a limited investigator after a claimed cop (either Batman or Zedd as Galadriel claimed)? To fake claim investigator? Why would Gir! lie about not visiting? Perhaps because saw a possible mass redirect evidence. Or pehaps it was a mass redirect with only a random chance to redirect each action that Night to batman.
Was the interrogation of Rorschach part of the game or was that just added to the Dawn post for giggles? The way it's explained by him it seems like he asked the moderator to cover for him lurking instead of posted in the away thread. Or he found out something he shouldn't have (moderator send a wrong PM to him maybe) and took him out of the game for a cycle instead of mod killing? If it really is not a game power then that shoots my reasoning about Dexter being Town because scum interrogated Rorschach and I don't see them have two take-people-out-of-the-game powers.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 14:13:34 GMT -5
Post by ComeToTheDarkSideWeHaveCookies on Oct 19, 2010 14:13:34 GMT -5
Was it a post restriction punishment?
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 14:20:43 GMT -5
Post by peekercpa on Oct 19, 2010 14:20:43 GMT -5
hey, look nord and batty. i have no clue just yet.
it just seemed odd and i wanted to put it out there.
because if puffy was redirected there by scum what in the world was galadriel doing there?
my only guess is that scum sent their limited investigator to do the kill not knowing that a sk was going to be there as well as a redirected (my guess by pfk) town vig.
well it doesn't take a fucking genius to figure out the rest of the fracking folks' costumes.
*chitter* *chitter* *squeek* *squeek* *hand wave* *hand:wave*
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 14:39:25 GMT -5
Post by Sister Coyote on Oct 19, 2010 14:39:25 GMT -5
<font style="font-size: 12px;">Was it a post restriction punishment? SQUEEK (I seem to recall that Rorschach said he did NOT have a post restriction, but would be posting "in character" while that particular discussion was going on during Day 1. I could be misremembering.) well it doesn't take a fucking genius to figure out the rest of the fracking folks' costumes. SQUEEK? (You don't think Blockey would have assigned roles to try to avoid just that?)
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 16:11:25 GMT -5
Post by peekercpa on Oct 19, 2010 16:11:25 GMT -5
oh jeebus.
sis. such was not my intent to ascribe roles to costumes. hell i don't even know what in the world half these folks are based on canon? the observation was merely along the lines of knowing what in the world they were doing regardless of what mask they may or may not have been wearing.
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 16:39:58 GMT -5
Post by BillMc on Oct 19, 2010 16:39:58 GMT -5
hey, look nord and batty. i have no clue just yet. it just seemed odd and i wanted to put it out there. because if puffy was redirected there by scum what in the world was galadriel doing there? my only guess is that scum sent their limited investigator to do the kill not knowing that a sk was going to be there as well as a redirected (my guess by pfk) town vig. well it doesn't take a fucking genius to figure out the rest of the fracking folks' costumes. *chitter* *chitter* *squeek* *squeek* *hand wave* *hand:wave* to repeat earlier comments/theories I believe Story/Maniac in his claim that he his some form of jack of all trades. However I don't believe that he is town (I agree with Story to disagree on that point). As he suggested, and I agree, someone had the power to redirect all killers to me on N2. It would have been a dumb move by a SK or Scum to target me - a 1 for 1 trade would not make sense. The only people not in the batcave by their own free will were killers. I also believe Story was responsible for said redirection ( again we agree to disagree on that point).
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 16:49:44 GMT -5
Post by Sister Coyote on Oct 19, 2010 16:49:44 GMT -5
The only people not in the batcave by their own free will were killers. SQUEEK! (Nitpick: The only people who DENIED being in the batcave of their own volition were killers -- Gir and Galadriel. We do not actually know that they were redirected, only that they claimed to have targeted other people. Which, you know, given that the so-far-as-we-know not killing types openly admitted to being there? May not have been any redirection at all, unless we're taking Scum and PFK at their words.)
|
|
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 16:50:40 GMT -5
Post by Sister Coyote on Oct 19, 2010 16:50:40 GMT -5
<font style="font-size: 12px;">oh jeebus. sis. such was not my intent to ascribe roles to costumes. hell i don't even know what in the world half these folks are based on canon? the observation was merely along the lines of knowing what in the world they were doing regardless of what mask they may or may not have been wearing. Squeek (I didn't think so, but I have learned it is almost always best to ask for clarification, you know?)
|
|
timmy
Mome Rath
In the frozen land of Nador they were forced to eat Robin's minstrels. And there was much rejoicing
Posts: 189
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day Six
Oct 19, 2010 17:15:38 GMT -5
Post by timmy on Oct 19, 2010 17:15:38 GMT -5
Was the interrogation of Rorschach part of the game or was that just added to the Dawn post for giggles?The way it's explained by him it seems like he asked the moderator to cover for him lurking instead of posted in the away thread. Or he found out something he shouldn't have (moderator send a wrong PM to him maybe) and took him out of the game for a cycle instead of mod killing? If it really is not a game power then that shoots my reasoning about Dexter being Town because scum interrogated Rorschach and I don't see them have two take-people-out-of-the-game powers. Can answer that. Interrogation happened as part of role. Has nothing to do with Scum, Town, or 3rd Party. Submitted action Night 4, was told I would be interrogated and not allowed to speak until Day 6. Dead Rat correct, no restrictions on posting during game. Never has been.
|
|