|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 15:19:10 GMT -5
Post by roxis on Jan 29, 2009 15:19:10 GMT -5
One further question for Roxis - have you ever fully explained the inconsistency in your belief in trophyifier as PFK/other vs. being scum? It seems you jumped straight into claiming without really defending that - I don't find you particularly scummy (just anti-town for not voting), but I'm curious about it. You don't find me scummy...but I'm your #1 vote. How does that make any sense? Also note that last night I did vote, but took it off when Mr Special Ed explained himself. Monday - Thursday I have school during the day, so unless I'm in the computer lab, I won't be on. Granted, I could have voted when I unvoted Ed, but I didn't. My inconsistencies were due to the fact that I was almost 'thinking aloud'. The wincon for SCUM vs. the wincon for Town made me think that SCUM had the power to trophyfy, and then Pollux's comment made me think that it could be the signature of a serial killer. Also, for the record, a serial killer isn't necessarily a PFK. In the first/only other game I played, there was a serial killer whose 'signature' was killing with clocks/leaving clock parts on the scene. She wasn't a malicious PFK, she was a serial killer aligned with scum. I don't think I ever referred to trophyfying as having to do with a PFK (besides my comment about the Mad Bomber which I never brought up again because I didn't think it probable). Roxis, I'm saying, the reason the scum would kill masons is because we're all confirmed/confirmable power roles. Especially given the fact that we all have individual titles. I don't think you meant me.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 15:21:51 GMT -5
Post by aubby on Jan 29, 2009 15:21:51 GMT -5
Odd that Ed said the scum know who they are because the traitor can tell them (which I agree is true as Pede confirmed on page 11 that scum can communicate during the day) but later in the their conversation Zeriel said "Because you see, the scum might not know about this yet--they can't strategerize during the day. "
Without the time stamps it's hard to say whether Ed knew about the scum talking during the day before or after Pede confirmed it.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 15:22:36 GMT -5
Post by Nanook on Jan 29, 2009 15:22:36 GMT -5
Man, a guy goes to bed and does some work before coming back to the thread and all hell has broken loose.
I think it's kinda funny that after all the games where people talked about and speculated on and dreaded evil masons, we finally get one and it isn't an end game worry at all, but jumps right out at us on Day 1.
Misterblockey
I'm not understanding your argument here. Why doesn't an investigative role make sense for a mason/scum mason? I don't see where the fact that she knows who the other masons are leads to the apparent conclusion that she would/could only use it on other masons. A mason watcher seems fine from a game standpoint, if a bit strong, and a scum watcher works as a way for them to pick out power roles among the town. Doubly so for scum actually, since they'll know when they watch someone that it's actually a town power role, as opposed to a Town one that doesn't know if it's a town or scum power role.
About the mason thread, the orignal posting was just a blank to me. Thanks for transcribing it misterB. I'm not sure how much help it is though.
Right now, I'm leaning towards Mitey, then Ed, then Zeriel. The magic bag, the wanting to wait a day, all are sort of suspicious to me. Ed is second because he's pinging me some. He's not first because it's just that, a ping, a feeling, not something concrete, plus his style of posting always comes across as scummy to me. Zeriel is hitting me as a forcefully aggressive townie trying to find the scum in his midst.
unvote all 1. Vote MiteyMouse 2. Vote SpecialEd 3. Vote Zeriel[/color]
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 15:22:52 GMT -5
Post by roxis on Jan 29, 2009 15:22:52 GMT -5
Roxis has claimed a killing role, and if I read her PM correctly, she can kill on Night Two. Earliest I can kill is Night Three, though they won't actually die until Day Four.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 15:34:46 GMT -5
Post by The Real FCOD on Jan 29, 2009 15:34:46 GMT -5
New Page Vote Count Votes: Player | Vote 1 | Vote 2 | Vote 3 | Aubby | Zeriel | | Koldanar | brokentree | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | crazypunker | Parzival | | | Hal Briston | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Hoopy Frood | crazypunker | | | Kat | MiteyMouse | Aubby | molefan | KidVermicious | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | misterblocky | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | MiteyMouse | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | molefan | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | Nanook | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Zeriel | Parzival | roxis | peekercpa | Zeriel | Pollux Oil | | Mr. Special Ed | brokentree | Sachertorte | Nanook | Koldanar | Hal Briston | shaggy | Koldanar | Parzival | shaggy | sinjin | | Parzival | | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | crazypunker | brokentree |
Totals: Votee | Total | Voters (#1) | Voters (#2) | Voters (#3) | Zeriel | 23 | Aubby, brokentree, Hal Briston, KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | molefan, Nanook, Parzival | MiteyMouse | 22 | Kat, molefan, Mr. Special Ed, Nanook, Zeriel | brokentree, Hal Briston | KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | 15 | | KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse, molefan, Nanook, Pollux Oil | brokentree, Hal Briston, Mr. Special Ed | Parzival | 7 | crazypunker | shaggy, sinjin | | Koldanar | 6 | shaggy | Sachertorte | Aubby | crazypunker | 5 | Hoopy Frood | Zeriel | | Nanook | 3 | Sachertorte | | | roxis | 3 | Parzival | | | brokentree | 2 | | | Pollux Oil, Zeriel | Aubby | 2 | | Kat | | peekercpa | 2 | | Parzival | | shaggy | 1 | | | shaggy | molefan | 1 | | | Kat | Hal Briston | 1 | | | Sachertorte |
Not Voting: Koldanar, Merestil Haye, peekercpa, roxis, Rysto, TDPatriots --FCOD
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 15:44:30 GMT -5
Post by Zeriel on Jan 29, 2009 15:44:30 GMT -5
Without the time stamps it's hard to say whether Ed knew about the scum talking during the day before or after Pede confirmed it. I'm not allowed to quote time stamps, but Pede confirmed the scum talk during the day yesterday (on page 11 of this thread) and Ed's comment about scum talking during the day was as early as Sunday.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 15:49:13 GMT -5
Post by Mister Blockey on Jan 29, 2009 15:49:13 GMT -5
Ok to put it another way Nanook
A member of the scum Who also is on the mason board, but secretly scum And also has investigative powers
seems absurdly overpowered to me.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:04:51 GMT -5
Post by roxis on Jan 29, 2009 16:04:51 GMT -5
Oh poop, forgot to vote.
Right now, I'm looking least towards Ed. While I did vote for him initially, he cleared all that up, so I'm not going to use that against him. I'd like to see his role PM to try and distinguish between Mitey and zeriel, though it really means nothing - he could be scum, though he's pinging me the least.
Mitey, however, posts almost nothing of substance until she starts to be attacked. She magic bags in the Mason thread ('cmon, at least breadcrumb). She doesn't want to claim early because if they do, scum might not nightkill the two Town Masons...but if the SCUM mason can communicate between both Masons and his/her scum buddies, SCUM would already know the identities of the two town Masons. They wouldn't kill one of the others anyway. Of course, until we can confirm that he/she can communicate with both Masons and SCUM, this is a null tell. Besides that, the fact that the two other Masons think of her as the most suspicious makes me suspicious of her too.
zeriel, like others have said, could just be a little overzealous. I know the feeling.
Until I have more to go on, I'm gonna:
Vote 1. Miteymouse Vote 2. zeriel Vote 3. Mr Special Ed
To be rearranged upon more information.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:07:37 GMT -5
Post by The Real FCOD on Jan 29, 2009 16:07:37 GMT -5
Hehe, you said poop. Votes: Player | Vote 1 | Vote 2 | Vote 3 | Aubby | Zeriel | | Koldanar | brokentree | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | crazypunker | Parzival | | | Hal Briston | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Hoopy Frood | crazypunker | | | Kat | MiteyMouse | Aubby | molefan | KidVermicious | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | misterblocky | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | MiteyMouse | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | molefan | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | Nanook | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Zeriel | Parzival | roxis | peekercpa | Zeriel | Pollux Oil | | Mr. Special Ed | brokentree | roxis | MiteyMouse | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | Sachertorte | Nanook | Koldanar | Hal Briston | shaggy | Koldanar | Parzival | shaggy | sinjin | | Parzival | | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | crazypunker | brokentree |
Totals: Votee | Total | Voters (#1) | Voters (#2) | Voters (#3) | MiteyMouse | 25 | Kat, molefan, Mr. Special Ed, Nanook, roxis, Zeriel | brokentree, Hal Briston | KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse | Zeriel | 25 | Aubby, brokentree, Hal Briston, KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed, roxis | molefan, Nanook, Parzival | Mr. Special Ed | 16 | | KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse, molefan, Nanook, Pollux Oil | brokentree, Hal Briston, Mr. Special Ed, roxis | Parzival | 7 | crazypunker | shaggy, sinjin | | Koldanar | 6 | shaggy | Sachertorte | Aubby | crazypunker | 5 | Hoopy Frood | Zeriel | | Nanook | 3 | Sachertorte | | | roxis | 3 | Parzival | | | brokentree | 2 | | | Pollux Oil, Zeriel | Aubby | 2 | | Kat | | peekercpa | 2 | | Parzival | | shaggy | 1 | | | shaggy | molefan | 1 | | | Kat | Hal Briston | 1 | | | Sachertorte |
Not Voting: Koldanar, Merestil Haye, peekercpa, Rysto, TDPatriots --FCOD
|
|
Merestil Haye
FGM
Grudge Keeper
[on:Slumming it in the Middle-Earth][of:In the halls of Manw
Posts: 1,077
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:09:05 GMT -5
Post by Merestil Haye on Jan 29, 2009 16:09:05 GMT -5
Now here's a right royal how-de-do. I mean, this goes beyond kerfuffle and even imbrogio into Donnybrook territory. A Masonic free-for-all, no less. Without the time stamps it's hard to say whether Ed knew about the scum talking during the day before or after Pede confirmed it. I'm not allowed to quote time stamps, but Pede confirmed the scum talk during the day yesterday (on page 11 of this thread) and Ed's comment about scum talking during the day was as early as Sunday. At least we're allowed to quote PMs in this game. I'm not at all sure who to vote for in this case, although (assuming that this story all hangs together) clearly we need to lynch a Mason. This fact alone should have the SCUM cackling like hyenas – the Mason group outedon Day 1 and the Town willingly going along in stringing them up! Suppose they – the three of them – are the SCUM? Bussing one of their own to leave the other two ironclad Townie cred? There, I've thought the unthinkable. The answer is, of course, that if they aren't the Masons, someone else probably is and can counterclaim. Which order I rank them depends on the results of my rereading the last 24 hours worth of posts. Oh my giddy aunt. Back before I go to bed Tonight with some blue-coloured text. I hope.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:11:24 GMT -5
Post by Mister Blockey on Jan 29, 2009 16:11:24 GMT -5
wow, and I was thinking ties were going to be highly unlikely in borda counts.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:23:03 GMT -5
Post by Zeriel on Jan 29, 2009 16:23:03 GMT -5
Overzealousness is kinda like my freakin' trademark. Ask NAF.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:35:55 GMT -5
Post by aubby on Jan 29, 2009 16:35:55 GMT -5
unvote all
Vote: 1. Zeriel 2. Mr Special Ed 3. Mitey Mouse
Ed still doesn't seem to confirm or deny. Not sure how to take that. Moves him above Mitey for me, tho.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:38:44 GMT -5
Post by roxis on Jan 29, 2009 16:38:44 GMT -5
Ed usually isn't on at this time, or at least, not that I've seen. I don't think he's posted since being asked, so he probably just hasn't been on. Give him a few hours.
|
|
Trepa Mayfield
FGM
Does Not Follow Directions
The only kind of panda worth preserving.
Posts: 989
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:48:04 GMT -5
Post by Trepa Mayfield on Jan 29, 2009 16:48:04 GMT -5
I'm posting the votecount again, because it shows Complete vs. Incomplete votes now. Votes: Player | Vote 1 | Vote 2 | Vote 3 | Aubby | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | brokentree | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | crazypunker | Parzival | | | Hal Briston | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Hoopy Frood | crazypunker | | | Kat | MiteyMouse | Aubby | molefan | KidVermicious | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | misterblocky | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | MiteyMouse | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | molefan | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | MiteyMouse | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | Nanook | MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed | Zeriel | Parzival | roxis | peekercpa | Zeriel | Pollux Oil | | Mr. Special Ed | brokentree | roxis | MiteyMouse | Zeriel | Mr. Special Ed | Sachertorte | Nanook | Koldanar | Hal Briston | shaggy | Koldanar | Parzival | shaggy | sinjin | | Parzival | | Zeriel | MiteyMouse | crazypunker | brokentree |
Totals: Votee | Total | Voters (#1) | Voters (#2) | Voters (#3) | MiteyMouse | 26 (26) | Kat, molefan, Mr. Special Ed, Nanook, roxis, Zeriel | brokentree, Hal Briston | Aubby, KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse | Zeriel | 25 (25) | Aubby, brokentree, Hal Briston, KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse | Mr. Special Ed, roxis | molefan, Nanook, Parzival | Mr. Special Ed | 18 (16) | | Aubby, KidVermicious, misterblocky, MiteyMouse, molefan, Nanook, Pollux Oil | brokentree, Hal Briston, Mr. Special Ed, roxis | Parzival | 7 (2) | crazypunker | shaggy, sinjin | | Koldanar | 5 (5) | shaggy | Sachertorte | | crazypunker | 5 (2) | Hoopy Frood | Zeriel | | Nanook | 3 (3) | Sachertorte | | | roxis | 3 (3) | Parzival | | | brokentree | 2 (1) | | | Pollux Oil, Zeriel | Aubby | 2 (2) | | Kat | | peekercpa | 2 (2) | | Parzival | | shaggy | 1 (1) | | | shaggy | molefan | 1 (1) | | | Kat | Hal Briston | 1 (1) | | | Sachertorte |
Not Voting: Koldanar, Merestil Haye, peekercpa, Rysto, TDPatriots
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 16:50:05 GMT -5
Post by The Real FCOD on Jan 29, 2009 16:50:05 GMT -5
In case it isn't obvious, the second number in the totals represents how many points each votee has if we remove the incomplete votes. Also, players that have not placed all three votes will appear in italic.
--FCOD
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 17:05:32 GMT -5
Post by Hal Briston on Jan 29, 2009 17:05:32 GMT -5
Suppose they – the three of them – are the SCUM? Bussing one of their own to leave the other two ironclad Townie cred? That'd be simply awesome. Town would have three scum in just a couple of days. Look at the progression: Day 1 -- town lynches scum, two Masons are confirmed. Night 1 -- a non-Mason dies. Night 2 -- a non-Mason dies. Night 3 -- a non-Mason dies. Right around this time, everyone would be thinking "Ummm...the hell? Why aren't the scum offing our confirmed Masons?" If they hadn't been investigated by then, it'd soon become clear enough. It'd be nice, but no, I don't see this being the case.
|
|
Merestil Haye
FGM
Grudge Keeper
[on:Slumming it in the Middle-Earth][of:In the halls of Manw
Posts: 1,077
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 17:28:06 GMT -5
Post by Merestil Haye on Jan 29, 2009 17:28:06 GMT -5
Suppose they – the three of them – are the SCUM? Bussing one of their own to leave the other two ironclad Townie cred? That'd be simply awesome. Town would have three scum in just a couple of days. Look at the progression: Day 1 -- town lynches scum, two Masons are confirmed. Night 1 -- a non-Mason dies. Night 2 -- a non-Mason dies. Night 3 -- a non-Mason dies. Right around this time, everyone would be thinking "Ummm...the hell? Why aren't the scum offing our confirmed Masons?" If they hadn't been investigated by then, it'd soon become clear enough. It'd be nice, but no, I don't see this being the case. I don't think it is probable, but not because they won't get killed; I don't see the SCUM attacking them for some time, say two Nights at least. The main reasons re that (a) any protective role is likely to focus their attention on the Masons in the absence of anything better, and (b) they might hit an investigator. Yes, I know it's a long shot, but look at some of the things that have happened and sometimes it's worth taking potluck and seeing what you come up with. As I said above, if they're the SCUM, then what about the real Masons?
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 17:35:51 GMT -5
Post by brokentree on Jan 29, 2009 17:35:51 GMT -5
That'd be simply awesome. Town would have three scum in just a couple of days. Look at the progression: Day 1 -- town lynches scum, two Masons are confirmed. Night 1 -- a non-Mason dies. Night 2 -- a non-Mason dies. Night 3 -- a non-Mason dies. Right around this time, everyone would be thinking "Ummm...the hell? Why aren't the scum offing our confirmed Masons?" If they hadn't been investigated by then, it'd soon become clear enough. It'd be nice, but no, I don't see this being the case. I don't think it is probable, but not because they won't get killed; I don't see the SCUM attacking them for some time, say two Nights at least. The main reasons re that (a) any protective role is likely to focus their attention on the Masons in the absence of anything better, and (b) they might hit an investigator. Yes, I know it's a long shot, but look at some of the things that have happened and sometimes it's worth taking potluck and seeing what you come up with. As I said above, if they're the SCUM, then what about the real Masons? I think I remember reading somewhere that Predescribe doesn't always use masons...
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 17:39:37 GMT -5
Post by Rysto on Jan 29, 2009 17:39:37 GMT -5
T2, ped's only ever game, did not have masons. It'd be a huge risk for scum to take Day 1, but it's certainly not impossible.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 17:40:14 GMT -5
Post by Rysto on Jan 29, 2009 17:40:14 GMT -5
NETA:
T2, ped's only other game
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 17:50:48 GMT -5
Post by brokentree on Jan 29, 2009 17:50:48 GMT -5
NETA: T2, ped's only other game Actually Ped is also the mod for a game on facebook.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 18:29:57 GMT -5
Post by special on Jan 29, 2009 18:29:57 GMT -5
I'm here and reading. trying to catch up. Hopefully one of my fellow masons has posted the thread by now. I'm only home briefly. I've got my daughter's band concert tonight. I will post the thread when I get home.
but don't hold your breath for anything useful. I can't see anything there, but maybe more eyes will help.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 18:32:31 GMT -5
Post by Høøpy Frøød on Jan 29, 2009 18:32:31 GMT -5
MiteyMouse, how did you expect your tracker ability to out the scum mason?
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 18:41:12 GMT -5
Post by MiteyMouse on Jan 29, 2009 18:41:12 GMT -5
MiteyMouse, how did you expect your tracker ability to out the scum mason? I'm hoping that I can track one of the other Masons and see who they target...if that person dies then I found the Scum.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 18:52:45 GMT -5
Post by special on Jan 29, 2009 18:52:45 GMT -5
Odd that Ed said the scum know who they are because the traitor can tell them (which I agree is true as Pede confirmed on page 11 that scum can communicate during the day) but later in the their conversation Zeriel said "Because you see, the scum might not know about this yet--they can't strategerize during the day. " Without the time stamps it's hard to say whether Ed knew about the scum talking during the day before or after Pede confirmed it. I suppose this might look odd. I wasn't worried about WHEN Scum would find out what we were saying. I was only concerned that Scum would find out(instantly or eventually) everything that occurred in the mason thread. This is the reason I didn't reveal my power in the mason thread. PM to follow soon. I'm ironing a skirt. I do apologize for not being around. I'm a teacher, and cannot access this site at all from work. t's blocked by our filtering software.
|
|
Merestil Haye
FGM
Grudge Keeper
[on:Slumming it in the Middle-Earth][of:In the halls of Manw
Posts: 1,077
[ Exalt | Smite ]
Karma:
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 18:55:49 GMT -5
Post by Merestil Haye on Jan 29, 2009 18:55:49 GMT -5
I've tried to think about who the SCUM Mason may be. Right now, I'm thinking in circles. I don't think there's going to be a smoking gun - no conclusive piece of evidence that shows who it is. I can either wait and see, or post a vote and then review the evidence free of the screaming demands to vote. A fast review of the three candidates. Mr Special Ed Pointers to SCUMminess; not much. Pointers against SCUMminess; He was all in favour of the Masons “coming out” to the main Thread Today. Complications : He hasn't said much Today, probably due to his employer blocking this site. I want to hear what he has to say, and particularly if he has a power. (On preview, I see he does.) A PM would be nice too. MiteyMouse Pointers to SCUMminess; “Magic Bagging,” wanted to delay coming out until Day 2. Pointers against SCUMminess; Her suggestion that her Watcher power can out the SCUMmy Mason wasn't well thought through (on the face of it) and is more likely to be the product of a single mind than a group. (Yes, she might not have told them. That's why it's a pointer and not a conclusive proof of innocence). It's possible (as MisterBlockey says) that Mitey's role is overpowered if she's a SCUM and a Mason and a Watcher. However, the Watcher is a likely candidate for a SCUM investigative ability. Zeriel Pointers to SCUMminess; That PM. The fact that he didn't get sent the Mason board info straight away might be to avoid him getting the two boards mixed up, then Pede forgot to send him the extra PM for a while. Pointers against SCUMminess; Unilateral action to reveal this imbroglio Today. On balance Zeriel tips the scales, just barely, over the Mouse. Can I vote for two first places please? No? Alright then. Vote 1. Zeriel 2. MiteyMouse 3. Mr Special EdRight at this moment, the third vote should be considered a proforma – if the first two are wrong the third must be right. I'll sleep on this and see what I think in the morning.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 19:07:01 GMT -5
Post by special on Jan 29, 2009 19:07:01 GMT -5
My PM does say town mason. Also different from Mitey's mine only lists the other 2 masons. It doesn't list myself. Zeriel'ss of course, listed nothing but a blank line like in the generic mason PM on the mason board.
Another thing that puzzles me, is why did Zeriel get a blank PM exactly like the generic one in the mason thread? Is it because he is scum and doesn't really have a power?
But, his PM does say Town like mine.
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 19:08:00 GMT -5
Post by peekercpa on Jan 29, 2009 19:08:00 GMT -5
Holy sheepdoodle.
And I post this because of the nature of who I am. A lot of my job is vetting proposed projects. As such I typically reduce to playing worst case scenarios. So we have three Masons all agreeing that one of them is scum. Let's accept that as gospel for now. We analyze correctly and kill a scum. That, unfortunately only gives us marginal assurance that the others are who they say they are. The only out is if mighty is being truthful about her powers. At some point she would be able to confirm herself and by default the other claimant. Say we lynch a Mason and they come back town. Well then we get to spend the better part of the next day listening to a debate between two souls (don't think scum would be so helpful as to NK the non scum Mason). And I apologize for not quoting directly but has already been mentioned what seems to be at worst a 1 for 2 exchange could really turn out to be 1 for 5 exchange. Town is not going to win that type of horse race very often. So while I do believe that one of our Masons should swing today it sure seems to have brewed up quick and in the scum's favor.
Since zeriel initiated it, ed suggested it on the Mason board and mouse wanted to defer but only by one day.
Vote 1 - Zeriel, 2 2 - ed, 3 - Mmouse
|
|
|
Day 1
Jan 29, 2009 19:15:23 GMT -5
Post by Zeriel on Jan 29, 2009 19:15:23 GMT -5
My PM does say town mason. Also different from Mitey's mine only lists the other 2 masons. It doesn't list myself. Zeriel'ss of course, listed nothing but a blank line like in the generic mason PM on the mason board. Thank you for that. I'm a lot more confident in my belief about MiteyMouse now at least. Bah, I didn't get exactly like, first of all, the salutation isn't in the mason blank one, and secondly, I do have a power. Pede confirmed in the Mason discussion thread that he did in fact screw up my PM the first time around. Honestly, I think the name/alignment/power line at the top ought to be enough for you folks--If I was the scum, why wouldn't I have copied Mitey to prevent this very thing. I had a whole 20 minutes after all (during which I was in a freakin' conference call but whatever ).
|
|